A new study in the field of organisational psychology probes how bosses who talk about their own ethical deeds at work affect their teams. The research, led by Grace Ching Chi Ho of Southern Methodist University and Hudson Sessions of Arizona State University, finds that such moral bragging can either uplift staff or put them off, depending on whether the manager also highlights the good deeds of others.
Researchers describe this dynamic as supervisor moral capitalisation. They distinguish between self-focused sharing—when a supervisor talks about their own ethical actions—and other-focused sharing—when the spotlight falls on colleagues’ or other leaders’ fair or compassionate acts.
“Leaders are often encouraged to use their own behaviour as an example of ethical conduct at work,” Ho told PsyPost. “Sharing how they showed compassion to an employee facing personal difficulties or honestly corrected an overcharge to a client can make ethical values tangible. However, calling attention to one’s own good deeds can also come across as morally superior or disingenuous.”
“Leaders therefore face a challenge: sharing their own ethical actions may help them build an ethical workplace, but it can also create negative impressions,” she added. “We wanted to understand this tension and how leaders might navigate it.”
What the research found
In their framework, praising one’s own virtuous acts can trigger two opposite moral emotions. Moral elevation is a warm, uplifting feeling that inspires imitation, while moral disgust is a chilly revulsion toward perceived hypocrisy or impurity.
The team conducted a three-wave field survey with 305 full‑time supervisors at the outset. Each supervisor nominated an employee they worked with closely to participate, with 285 employees and 285 supervisors responding in the second and third waves, yielding a final sample of 254 supervisor–employee pairs who had worked together for around three years on average.
In the first survey, supervisors reported how often they had shared their own ethical actions and how often they had highlighted the ethical actions of others. Weeks later, employees assessed how much their interactions left them feeling morally elevated or disgusted. In the final wave, supervisors evaluated how much voluntary help they had recently received from the employee.
The researchers also accounted for broader moral humility in supervisors and ran checks adjusting for routine celebrations of work wins or displays of pride to ensure the results reflected something beyond general optimism.
Across the sample, frequent self-focused moral sharing tended to align with higher reports of employees’ moral elevation, which in turn related to more helpful behaviour toward the supervisor. Yet the researchers stress that these links are correlational rather than direct evidence of causation.
Crucially, self-focused sharing on its own did not show a statistically significant link with employee disgust. A pattern emerged when the researchers looked at whether supervisors also talked up others’ good deeds. Among managers who rarely highlighted others, talking about one’s own morality was associated with greater disgust and, in turn, less helpfulness. Conversely, for supervisors who did regularly praise colleagues, self-focused moral sharing did not show the same negative association, and in some cases connected to stronger moral elevation.
A gender difference also surfaced. In the field data, self-focused moral sharing correlated with stronger employee disgust when the supervisor identified as a woman, compared with male supervisors. The authors suggest publicly recognising leaders’ ethical contributions—such as through formal awards—might help offset this penalty by reducing the need for self-promotion.
What happened in the lab
The researchers ran a preregistered experiment with 233 full‑time U.S. employees, testing whether a single interaction could spark the same emotional reactions observed in the field. Participants watched a simulated Slack chat in which a supervisor called Jamie discussed the week’s events with an employee.
Participants were randomly assigned to one of four versions. In the high self-focused condition, Jamie described personal ethical choices—like declining a vendor referral to avoid a conflict of interest, showing compassion to a stressed colleague, and returning an overpayment honestly. In the low self-focused condition, the supervisor shared routine updates.
Immediately after, Jamie shifted to updates about other coworkers, either praising colleagues’ ethical behaviour or mentioning mundane tasks. After the exchange, participants rated moral elevation, disgust, and their willingness to help Jamie.
As in the field, seeing personal ethical choices sparked greater moral elevation than routine updates, and higher elevation was linked to a greater willingness to help. The authors note the link is correlational since emotions and intentions were measured simultaneously after the video.
The overall disgust response was not statistically significant across the board. Disgust ratings were low in both the field and lab studies, and the authors acknowledge that people may be reluctant to report negative emotions in such settings.
When coworkers’ recognition was included, a split emerged. If Jamie discussed personal deeds while giving only routine credit to colleagues, disgust rose and willingness to help fell. If Jamie paired personal moral stories with praise for coworkers’ kindness, the direct effect on disgust was not significant, though, in the full path model, lower disgust was associated with greater willingness to help.
The lab also included a parallel comparison between moral sharing and sharing ordinary performance wins, finding that disgust appeared distinctive to moral boasting rather than simple bragging about work wins.
Practical implications for leaders
The researchers emphasise a straightforward takeaway: leaders should share the spotlight by recognising others’ ethical actions alongside their own. This approach, they say, helps model ethical values without alienating staff.
There are caveats. In the field study, supervisors chose which employee to invite, which could bias the sample toward more cooperative pairs. And the Slack experiment measured participants’ willingness to help a fictional manager, not actual workplace actions. Ho also stressed that a negative worker reaction does not necessarily mean a supervisor’s good deed was insincere, and the study did not presuppose a particular motive behind the actions.
Beyond the laboratory and the office, the authors suggest the broader context of organisational culture may shape how moral talk is received. They note that mission-driven workplaces such as hospitals, charities, or religious organisations might welcome moral stories more readily than sectors viewed with public scepticism, like tobacco or gambling. They also propose further research into how personal moral values shape responses to different types of moral storytelling and how inclusive language might influence reception.
The study, “Uplifting or Off-Putting? The Effects of Supervisors Capitalizing on Their Involvement in Positive Moral Events on Employee Outcomes,” was authored by Grace Ching Chi Ho and Hudson Sessions.
