A study led by Erik Ilkevič at Vilnius University suggests that men who routinely reframe upsetting situations can manage mild negative emotions more effectively when their baseline cortisol levels are higher. The researchers found no reliable link between resting testosterone and emotional control, pointing to a joint relationship between everyday psychological habits and baseline stress hormones in handling mild distress.
Emotion regulation refers to the mental processes people use to change the intensity, duration or expression of their feelings. A widely studied conscious strategy is cognitive reappraisal, where a person reinterprets an upsetting scene to soften its emotional impact. Effective use of this approach is linked to better psychological well‑being, while difficulties with regulating emotions are common across many psychiatric disorders.
The reappraisal process relies on communication between the prefrontal cortex and the amygdala, brain regions involved in self‑control and threat response. Both areas contain receptors for cortisol, the body’s primary stress‑adaptation hormone, and testosterone, which influences social behaviour in addition to its reproductive role.
Earlier work indicated that temporary cortisol spikes can aid emotional reframing in men. For example, a 2020 experiment found that men subjected to a stressful public‑speaking evaluation before viewing unpleasant images were more successful at reframing their emotions than unstressed men, an effect linked to cortisol release. Similar benefits were observed when cortisol was administered in pill form.
The researchers also situate their work within the dual‑hormone framework, which proposes that testosterone’s influence on behaviour often depends on cortisol levels. A 2025 study by two of the same authors found that higher resting testosterone predicted lower perceived stress after a social challenge only when cortisol was low, while higher cortisol predicted lower stress only when testosterone was low.
Aiming to understand how resting hormones relate to real‑world emotion regulation, Ilkevič, senior author Ramunė Grikšienė and colleagues tested whether resting cortisol and testosterone jointly relate to reappraisal performance and whether everyday reappraisal habits alter those links.
The study recruited 140 Lithuanian men aged 20 to 36, with two exclusions for pre‑existing psychiatric diagnoses leaving 138 for analyses and one statistical outlier removed to yield 137 in the regression models. Participants visited the lab for a three‑hour session, during which they completed questionnaires on recent anxiety and depression and how often they use cognitive reappraisal or emotional suppression in daily life.
Saliva samples were taken during the visit to measure baseline cortisol and testosterone using a high‑precision analytical method. Participants then completed a 25‑minute computer task involving 72 photographs of people, including neutral scenes and unpleasant scenes ranging from mild distress to severe injuries, presented at six seconds each.
For half of the unpleasant images, participants passively viewed them; for the other half they were asked to actively reframe the scene in a more positive light or imagine a better outcome. Reframing instructions asked for realistic reinterpretations, such as imagining that a crying child’s parents are on their way to help.
Participants then rated how negatively each image affected them on a 1–100 scale. The researchers used regression analyses that adjusted for body mass index, the time of saliva collection, and each man’s ratings during passive viewing of images of matching intensity.
Across the whole sample, images of greater distress were rated more negatively, and active reappraisal reduced negative ratings at both mild and severe intensities. However, baseline cortisol, baseline testosterone, and the interaction between the two hormones did not predict reframing performance in the full group.
A clearer pattern emerged when the data were limited to men with high habitual reappraisal use. Among these participants, higher resting cortisol was linked to lower negative feelings during active reframing of mild images, though the effect was small. In contrast, cortisol did not show a significant association among men with average or low habitual reappraisal.
“Even though the effect was small, it aligns well with the current literature showing positive effects of cortisol on emotion regulation,” Ilkevič said. “Given that these findings were present only for the slightly negative pictures and only among participants who often use this strategy in daily life, it confirms the idea that hormones should not be investigated in isolation. Hormonal effects are highly context‑dependent; therefore, they must be investigated while considering environment, other hormones, participants’ psychological characteristics, and other relevant factors.”
He added: “The effect size we observed was small, suggesting that factors beyond hormonal levels should be considered. On the one hand, this is revealing because our emotion regulation abilities are not determined by hormonal levels, even though hormones have a significant impact.”
In exploratory analyses, strong everyday reappraisal predicted better laboratory regulation when resting cortisol was high but unexpectedly predicted worse regulation when resting cortisol was low. The researchers described the p‑values for these slopes as marginal, noting they narrowly exceeded the conventional 0.05 threshold, and urged cautious interpretation.
When participants viewed high‑intensity graphic scenes, none of the hormonal or habitual factors showed statistically significant associations, and neither baseline testosterone nor habitual emotional suppression yielded effects in any model.
Explaining the absence of broad cortisol effects, the authors proposed that resting cortisol interacts mainly with high‑sensitivity receptors in the brain, whereas large cortisol spikes activate lower‑sensitivity receptors. They suggested that a mild baseline signal may fine‑tune prefrontal–amygdala circuits in men who routinely practice reappraisal, but intense images may overwhelm such strategies.
As for testosterone, the researchers found no behavioural link. “Surprisingly, we did not observe any robust findings with basal testosterone, even though some other studies suggest that testosterone is associated with impaired emotion regulation,” Ilkevič said. “However, that is actually good news – it means that even those males with higher testosterone levels can successfully engage in cognitive reappraisal and thus effectively regulate their emotions.”
Beyond the current findings, Ilkevič argued for rehabilitating public perceptions of hormones. “We would like to rehabilitate cortisol a bit. Chronic elevations of cortisol concentrations are, of course, unhealthy, but the optimal basal levels and appropriate cortisol responses to acute stressors are important for the health of both body and mind.”
“Similarly, we also would like to rehabilitate testosterone,” he continued. “Stereotypically, testosterone is often assumed to be related to aggression and anger, although the actual literature shows a much more complex picture of testosterone that is heavily context‑dependent and cannot be considered in isolation from both environmental and individual factors.” He warned against assuming testosterone would automatically hamper cognitive reappraisal, noting: “these findings should further remind us that our assumptions might be wrong and that there is much we still do not understand about the complex hormonal interactions.”
The authors caution that the study’s cross‑sectional design cannot establish causality, and the sample consisted only of healthy young Lithuanian men, limiting generalisability to women, older adults or clinical groups. They also acknowledged measurement noise from a self‑report habit questionnaire and the use of self‑reported emotional ratings rather than physiological markers.
The team plans further work, including experiments that manipulate hormone levels, enrol female participants, and incorporate physiological measures such as brain activity and pupil dilation to examine how basal hormone levels relate to emotion resilience across different regulation strategies. They are also extending their work to explore harm aversion and its link to proactive aggression using laboratory measures.
The study, “Investigating associations between cortisol, testosterone and emotion regulation in healthy young men,” was authored by Erik Ilkevič, Ingrida Zelionkaitė, Eglė Mazgelytė, Violeta Cimalanskaitė-Kazlauskienė, Dovilė Karčiauskaitė, Algirdas Utkus, Markus Hausmann, and Ramunė Grikšienė.
