A newly devised questionnaire suggests that children and teenagers who spent more time listening to classical music are more likely to enjoy complex genres such as jazz and opera. The findings, published in Psychology of Music, were led by Valnea Žauhar of the University of Rijeka in Croatia, with colleagues Igor Bajšanski and Sabina Vidulin, and describe a tool called the Past Experience with Listening to Classical Music Scale.
In the study, researchers frame what constitutes “sophisticated music” within the MUSIC model: genres such as classical, opera, jazz and world music, which are generally instrumental and perceived as complex, intelligent and inspiring.
Many young people, however, gravitate towards pop, rock or contemporary music in daily life and rarely use sophisticated music to regulate mood or socialise. The researchers note that music education programmes frequently aim to widen appreciation for classical music among younger generations.
Open to a range of musical styles in childhood, the researchers say, openness narrows during adolescence as preferences align with peer groups. As people move into adulthood, the willingness to explore diverse musical styles tends to rebound.
In their first study, 151 students aged 15 to 18 from a general secondary school listened to six 15-second clips of sophisticated music and rated how much they liked each piece. The researchers deliberately chose obscure, unreleased tracks to ensure judgments could be based on the music itself rather than familiarity.
After the listening task, participants completed the newly developed Past Experience with Listening to Classical Music Scale, along with surveys detailing their general music consumption and the purposes for listening—emotional listening, cognitive listening or background listening. Emotional listening concerns using music to change mood, while cognitive listening involves analysing musical elements intellectually.
The secondary school students generally reported low levels of past experience with classical music. Those with more past experience were more likely to use music for emotional and cognitive purposes and were also more likely to rate the sophisticated excerpts favourably.
At first, formal music education appeared to predict a preference for sophisticated music. However, once past experience with classical music was factored into the analysis, formal training no longer predicted liking. Positive emotional experiences with classical music in the past emerged as the sole positive predictor of liking the clips, suggesting emotional engagement is linked to taste irrespective of instruction.
A second study involved 286 primary school children aged eight to 14, tested during a regular group music lesson. They listened to a two-minute excerpt from Antonín Dvořák’s Symphony No. 9, From the New World, chosen for its energetic, expressive brass and rhythm.
Immediately after listening, the children rated how much they liked the music and how immersed they felt, then completed the past experience questionnaire and a survey of the emotions evoked, such as activation or calmness.
The children generally liked the Dvořák excerpt and reported moderate to moderately high levels of emotional activation. Past experience with classical music reliably predicted how much they enjoyed the piece, with older children and those having more exposure showing higher enjoyment. The strongest predictor of liking was the level of emotional activation experienced during listening; calmness did not predict preference for the fast-paced extract.
The researchers acknowledge that the findings rely on self-reported data, which depends on accurate recall of past listening habits. They emphasise that the concept of experience with classical music is multifaceted and suggest future work tracking participants over longer periods, potentially including parental or teacher records of exposure.
Because the studies focused on children and teenagers, the results do not necessarily translate to adulthood. A longitudinal approach following the same individuals as they age could offer a clearer picture of how early exposure shapes lifelong tastes.
The study entitled “The Role of Past Experience With Listening to Classical Music in Liking Sophisticated Music” is authored by Valnea Žauhar, Igor Bajšanski and Sabina Vidulin.
