The jury in the South Australian Supreme Court murder trial of Raelene Polymiaidis has retired to consider verdicts over the alleged insulin deaths of her elderly parents.
Polymiaidis, 65, denies two counts of murder. Her parents, Brenda and Lynton Anderson, were both 94 when they died, in March 2022 and May 2023 respectively.
The 12-person jury began its deliberations at 1.16pm on Thursday, after a trial that started on June 15 and had been expected to last three months. It is now in its sixth month.
Prosecutors allege Polymiaidis, who has type 1 diabetes, injected both her parents with insulin as their health declined and they faced the prospect of moving into aged care.
Brenda Anderson was admitted to Noarlunga Hospital after a fall in February 2022 left her with a fractured vertebra, pneumonia and another fall. The prosecution alleges Polymiaidis administered insulin to her mother during a visit on March 12 and again between March 13 and 15.
Mrs Anderson was found largely unresponsive by nursing staff after her daughter’s visit. Prosecutor Michael Foundas told jurors: “It was the insulin that killed her.”
Lynton Anderson remained at home after his wife’s death, although he became increasingly frail. His four children began taking turns to stay with him overnight.
Polymiaidis left the house on April 30, 2023, after spending the weekend with her father. A carer found Mr Anderson unconscious two hours later, and he died on May 1 from insulin toxicity, the prosecution alleges.
A central part of the case has been recordings made by a police listening device. On June 20, 2023, the day Polymiaidis was interviewed by Major Crime detectives, she was recorded alone in her car praying to God.
Mr Foundas described the recording as a “clear and unambiguous confession”. In it, Polymiaidis said: “Please, Lord, you know, yes, I have sinned. I have. Thou shall not kill.”
She also said: “I have sinned twice in my life, and I hate it, but I also know … your blessing, Lord, that they did not want to go to a nursing home, that was their wish.”
The prosecution has suggested that a possible motive was a misplaced belief that killing her parents would spare them from entering a nursing home.
Defence counsel Marie Shaw KC disputed the interpretation of the recordings, asking whether Polymiaidis was admitting responsibility or telling God that she felt responsible for their deaths. The defence also challenged the reliability of blood samples and expert evidence about insulin, including the possibility of contamination.
