A cross‑cultural study of more than 15,000 adults across Canada, the United States and Japan has found that personality traits linked to the Big Five are associated with small differences in the number of biological children, with the relationship varying by country and by major demographic factors such as marriage and age. The research, published in Culture and Evolution, was led by Maryanne L. Fisher of Saint Mary’s University in Halifax, Nova Scotia.
In evolutionary psychology, the Big Five framework measures five broad personality dimensions: openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism. The study defined reproductive success as the number of biological children a person has, and explored how these traits might influence partner selection, relationship stability and ultimately family size across three distinct cultures.
The researchers note that, in Western populations, prior work suggested patterns such as higher extraversion and openness and lower neuroticism among those with more children. They asked whether these patterns persist in Canada, the United States and Japan, where cultural values and gender norms differ. Fisher said Japan, in particular, offers a useful contrast given its notably lower birth rate.
The data were collected from February to March 2022 via an online survey, with 15,120 adults aged 20 or older participating (5,040 per country, evenly split by sex across five age bands). The questions about personality and children were part of a broader survey on public health habits and attitudes toward COVID‑19 vaccination; responses were gathered in Japanese for Japan, and in English for the United States and Canada, with Canadians offered a French option that none selected.
Initial analyses showed demographics explained about 21 per cent of the variation in the number of children. Being married, female, older, and in a heterosexual marriage were all linked with more biological children. Country of residence mattered as well: respondents in the United States and Canada reported more children than those in Japan, a pattern that aligns with the differently reported birth rates across the three nations.
When the Big Five traits were added to the model, they improved statistical fit but did not substantially increase explained variation beyond the demographic factors. Across the whole sample, higher scores on extraversion and agreeableness tended to correspond with slightly more biological children, while higher neuroticism slightly reduced the number of children. Conscientiousness and openness to experience did not show statistically reliable associations.
“The effects are small but important,” Fisher explained. “Personally, I think of personality here as being one of several factors that relate to one’s number of children. I definitely would discourage thinking of it as predicting the outcome of any individual’s family size until further work is done.”
Analyses also revealed that country modified how personality related to childbearing. Even after accounting for relationship status and sex, the links between personality and the number of offspring varied by country, with Canada and the United States showing more similarity to each other and Japan standing apart from the North American samples.
In terms of sex differences, the researchers’ predictions about a universal pattern tied to national gender equality were not borne out. Canada displayed a more nuanced pattern, while the United States and Japan showed men scoring higher than women on extraversion and agreeableness, and women higher on neuroticism and openness. Canada, however, did not exhibit a uniform female advantage across all traits, with men scoring higher on extraversion, agreeableness and conscientiousness and women higher only on neuroticism; openness did not differ significantly between the sexes there.
The findings echo earlier longitudinal work linking parenthood expectations with personality traits, suggesting extraversion and agreeableness correlate with expectations to become parents, while men in that group showed lower neuroticism. However, the new study measures actual fertility rather than expectations, and the authors acknowledge important differences between the two approaches.
One paradoxical result was the null finding for conscientiousness, which diverges from some international studies that highlighted conscientiousness as a positive predictor of family size. The authors propose competing behavioural forces: highly conscientious people might attract partners yet also prioritise careful family planning or financial security, postponing or limiting childbearing. Similarly, openness to experience did not predict larger families in this sample, contrary to earlier research that found such links in more unmarried populations where openness to new social connections could influence childbearing choices.
Fisher underscored the study’s limitations: personality and family size were measured at a single time point via a brief ten‑item scale, and all responses were self‑reported. The researchers caution against interpreting correlations as causation and note that the design cannot determine whether personality influences the decision to have children or whether raising children reshapes personality over time. They also point out that planned versus unplanned pregnancies and fertility difficulties were not distinguished in the data.
Looking ahead, Fisher expressed an interest in deeper work on gender equality and fertility, including population decline and how women’s perceived autonomy in reproductive decisions interacts with personality. She emphasised the need for longitudinal research to unpack how narrower facets of personality, alongside economic pressures and values, shape family formation in different cultural settings.
The study, titled How many? The Big Five and the number of children across three cultures, involved Maryanne L. Fisher, T. Joel Wade, Hidenori Komatsu, Nobuyuki Tanaka, Hiromi Kubota, Rebecca Burch, Catherine Salmon and David Widman.
