A new study led by researchers at Queen’s University in Kingston, Ontario, suggests that what people find sexually arousing is only moderately fixed across adulthood. The work finds turn-ons shift across time and life experiences, with small-to-moderate differences linked to age, race, gender, sexual orientation, education and religion, while shifts in arousal triggers do not appear to impact anxiety, depression or sexual difficulties.
Turn-on fluidity observed across adulthood
Turn-ons are the specific qualities, situations, or sensations that spark sexual arousal, ranging from a partner’s physical features and personality traits to the emotional bond between partners. Researchers describe “turn-on fluidity” as the degree to which what arouses someone changes over time, through personal experiences or across relationships. The authors note that previous work on sexual fluidity largely focused on attraction, identity or orientation, leaving the question of arousal triggers less explored.
The study is described as exploratory, with participants asked to rate five statements on a 0-to-10 scale about whether their turn-ons had always been the same, had changed over time, or shifted with life experiences, relationship status or relationship length. The researchers emphasise that the project sought to map whether triggers shift and how this relates to well-being, rather than establish causality.
Between November 2022 and January 2023, English-speaking adults were recruited via social media for a survey on legal, consensual sexual preferences. After screening, the final sample comprised 343 adults with an average age of 31.6, mostly from Canada and the United States. About half identified as women, just over a third as men, and around one in ten as gender-diverse. Most respondents were white and had post-secondary education, with nearly half identifying as heterosexual and about 30 per cent as bisexual or pansexual; smaller shares identified as gay or lesbian or various other minority identities.
The five items were answered on a 0-to-10 scale with no preset definition of “turn-on.” For two items, the first asked whether turn-ons had always been the same (reverse-scored to reflect change), and the others queried whether they had changed over time, or shifted with life experiences, relationship status, or relationship length. About three-quarters of respondents indicated non-identical answers across the items, suggesting some degree of fluidity overall.
Participants also completed five validated measures of well-being, including anxiety and depression scales covering the prior two weeks, plus assessments of sexual distress, sexual dysfunction and sexual flexibility related to bedroom problems.
The researchers note that the study was cross-sectional and did not include public data sharing, so the dataset is not posted online. They caution that one-time responses cannot disentangle aging effects from generational differences or imperfect recall, and that the survey did not directly measure relationship duration.
“The strongest and most consistent finding was that turn-on fluidity was present across the sample,” the researchers wrote. “Differences between demographic groups existed, but they were generally small to moderate in size and should be interpreted cautiously. The practical significance may be less about predicting who will experience fluidity and more about recognising that changes in turn-ons are a relatively common part of people’s sexual experiences.”
The authors, Melody Garas and Caroline Pukall, emphasise the exploratory nature of the work. Garas, a psychology graduate student, and Pukall, a professor of psychology and Canada Research Chair in Sexual Health at Queen’s University, describe her as directing the Sexual Health Research Lab and as editor of the textbook Human Sexuality: A Contemporary Introduction.
Garas and Pukall also reflect on what the findings could mean for broader sexual well-being, noting that the relationship between turn-on fluidity and mental health is not straightforward. They observed no statistically significant link between the five fluidity measures and anxiety, depression, sexual distress, sexual dysfunction or sexual flexibility.
They state: “Given that sexual well-being is often closely linked to broader psychological well-being, we expected there might be at least some association. Instead, the results suggest that changes in turn-ons themselves may be relatively neutral from a well-being perspective.”
The data hint at several demographic patterns. Younger adults tended to report slightly more non-sameness in their turn-ons over time, while other items showed less robust age effects. Bisexual and pansexual participants reported more non-sameness than heterosexual participants on at least one of the turn-on questions, whereas other orientation groups did not show consistent differences. Gender-diverse respondents reported lower fluidity on shifts tied to relationship status than cisgender participants, with other items showing no significant gender differences.
Racial comparisons revealed that white participants reported more change over time in their turn-ons than East Asian participants, though differences on the question of whether turn-ons had always been the same were not statistically significant. Education showed a similar pattern: post-secondary graduates reported more relationship-length shifts than high school graduates, while differences between single and partnered adults were not significant on any item. Religious affiliation produced the broadest group effects, with Christians reporting lower fluidity on some items than atheists and non-religious or spiritual respondents, and Jewish participants reporting higher fluidity on several items. The authors urge caution with these findings given the small sizes of some subgroups and inconsistent pairwise significance.
“The main takeaway is that turn-ons do not appear to be completely fixed for many people,” Garas and Pukall added. “Participants generally reported moderate levels of change in their turn-ons over time and across experiences, suggesting that it is common for what people find sexually appealing to evolve throughout life. At the same time, we found no evidence that having more fluid turn-ons was associated with poorer psychological or sexual well-being, which may be reassuring for people who notice changes in what they find arousing.”
Despite these encouraging notes, the researchers stress caution. The study’s cross-sectional design means it cannot reveal why turn-ons change or establish cause and effect, and the five single-item measures may be interpreted differently by respondents who blend physical arousal, attraction and sex drive. A substantial portion of initial responses went unfinished, and some subgroups—such as East Asian and Jewish respondents—were small, making those differences tentative until validated in larger samples.
Looking ahead, Garas and Pukall advocate longitudinal studies that follow the same individuals over several years to determine whether turn-ons evolve naturally or in response to specific experiences. They also welcome qualitative interviews to explore how adults define arousal triggers and sexual satisfaction. “One important next step is to develop and validate more comprehensive measures of turn-on fluidity,” they said. “Longitudinal and qualitative research will be especially valuable for answering these questions.”
The study, titled Turn-on fluidity and its relationship with psychological and sexual wellbeing: an exploratory analysis, was authored by Melody Garas, Rebecca Star and Caroline F. Pukall.
