Tim Hortons’ mobile app has been found to share sensitive user data with Forter, an Israeli cybertechnology company founded by former members of the country’s Unit 8200 intelligence division, according to a Canadian advocacy group.
Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (CJPME) identified Forter as the third-party recipient after an investigation into the coffee chain’s data practices raised concerns about information being transmitted from the app.
Research by computer science expert Joel Reardon found that the app began sending information to an overseas third party as soon as it was opened. The broadcaster that reported the findings did not initially identify the recipient.
Data shared by Tim Hortons app
CJPME said it contacted Mr Reardon, a researcher at the University of Calgary, to establish the identity and location of the company receiving the data.
The information included unique device identifiers, camera specifications, lists of device sensors, and the names of users’ ringtones and alarm sounds. It also contained the names of nearby Wi-Fi routers, which Mr Reardon said could potentially be used to determine a person’s location.
Researchers said the data could be used to create a digital fingerprint of individual devices.
Tim Hortons said the app collects information for fraud prevention, account protection and preventing payment abuse, rather than for marketing or advertising. The company also said neither it nor the third-party recipient sells users’ personal information.
Forter’s founders, Michael Reitblat, Liron Damri and Alon Shemesh, are alumni of Unit 8200, Israel’s signals intelligence and cyberwarfare division. The company says it uses machine-learning technology to identify potentially fraudulent transactions and highlights the founders’ experience in Israeli military intelligence.
Unit 8200, Israel’s largest single military unit, has faced scrutiny over its role in the surveillance of Palestinians in occupied territory. Microsoft barred the unit from using its technology last year after discovering that its systems had been used in surveillance operations against Palestinians.
Michael Bueckert, CJPME’s vice-president, said the app’s data-sharing arrangements raised ethical and cybersecurity concerns.
“Canadians ordering coffee should not have their unique and sensitive user data shared with an Israeli cyber-tech company whose infrastructure was built by alumni of a foreign military intelligence agency engaged in human rights violations,” he said.
“The company’s ties to an Israeli military unit that oversees the mass surveillance of Palestinians pose significant ethical issues, raising alarm bells for anyone concerned about cyber-security. Tim Hortons must cut ties with this company immediately,” he added.
