Generic rejection emails can damage an employer’s brand and discourage unsuccessful candidates from applying again, buying from the company or recommending it to others, research and recruitment experts have warned.
The warning comes as jobseekers face lengthy recruitment processes involving applications, skills tests, references and several rounds of interviews, only to receive a brief message saying their application will not progress – or no response at all.
Vicki Salemi, a career expert at Monster and former corporate recruiter, said companies risk undermining the employer brands they spend time and money building if they neglect the candidate experience.
“When employers spend money on branding, but don’t focus on the candidate experience, they’re missing out on the big picture,” she said.
Generic rejection emails weaken employer appeal
A study published in February in the International Journal of Selection and Assessment found that a standard rejection letter could significantly reduce how attractive a company appeared to potential employees.
The researchers surveyed 236 working adults and final-year students in the Netherlands and Belgium. Participants assessed fictional employers before and after receiving either a generic rejection or a message that acknowledged their effort.
Among those shown a company with a strong employer brand, its attractiveness score fell from 3.29 to 2.61 after a standard rejection. Although the score rose to 2.89 several days later, it remained below its original level.
There was no statistically significant fall among participants who received an appreciative rejection.
Sanne Fijneman-Ghielen, a Tilburg University researcher and lead author of the study, said: “The higher the employer brand equity, the more to lose with sending a generic rejection email.”
The appreciative message used in the research recognised the applicant’s interest and effort, explained that another candidate had more relevant industry experience, encouraged them to apply again and offered a discount code as a gesture of thanks.
Fijneman-Ghielen said the example showed that employers could express appreciation without providing detailed, individual feedback when they did not have enough information about a candidate’s qualifications.
Rejected applicants may also be customers
The effects of a poor hiring experience can extend beyond recruitment. An April LiveCareer survey of 1,008 US workers found that 48% would not apply to a company again after being ghosted, while 42% would trust it less and 37% would tell other people about what happened.
Ghosting was reported to be becoming more common, with 53% of jobseekers saying an employer had failed to respond to them in the previous year, according to a report from Criteria.
A separate July survey by recruitment assessment company Selection Lab found that 34.1% of ghosted applicants had told friends or family about the experience. Some 22.3% said they would never apply to the company again, while 4.2% had shared their experience online and 2.6% had stopped buying its products or services.
In an August PeopleScout survey of more than 1,000 jobseekers across 10 markets, 36% of candidates who reported a negative hiring experience said they would stop purchasing from the company. A further 37% said they would discourage others from applying.
Salemi said candidates who felt respected could still consider future vacancies, recommend the business to friends or remain loyal customers. Those who felt dismissed might do the opposite.
Recruiter workloads are not an excuse
Recruiters may be handling several vacancies, reviewing hundreds or thousands of applications, arranging interviews and monitoring measures such as time to fill. Salemi said those pressures could cause communication with unsuccessful candidates to be overlooked, but did not excuse the practice.
Technology is already being used to reduce the time involved. Melissa Shannon, a recruiter at Greenhouse, described using artificial intelligence to draft personalised rejection messages for candidates who had completed on-site interviews.
The system reads interview scorecards and notes before producing a draft that recognises a candidate’s strengths and areas for development. A recruiter then checks it for accuracy.
Shannon said the process reduced drafting time from between 20 and 30 minutes per candidate to less than three minutes.
“Ultimately, rejecting finalist candidates comes down to priorities and accountability,” Salemi said. “This stems from the top—from leadership and the company culture.”
Finalists deserve more than an automated message
A basic rejection still provides an answer, which can help a jobseeker move on. Jasmine Escalera, a career expert at LiveCareer, said a timely decision gave candidates closure and allowed them to focus their efforts on other opportunities.
But Salemi said people who had completed several interviews should not receive the same message as someone who had only submitted an application.
She recalled calling unsuccessful candidates when she worked in corporate recruitment. Some thanked her for making the call, despite having wanted the job, because they felt the company had taken the time to acknowledge them as individuals.
Employers could make such conversations more manageable with standardised scripts or email templates that recruiters personalise, she said.
Salemi also cited the Dutch beauty and lifestyle retailer Rituals, where interviewees were given two miniature bath foams – one to keep and one to give away – as an expression of the company’s philosophy of giving.
“Ultimately, rejecting candidates in a timely manner, especially when they reach the final rounds of interviews, isn’t just about protecting the employer’s reputation and/or brand,” Salemi said. “It’s about doing the right thing: Treating people with dignity and respect.”
