Prosecutors say there is currently insufficient evidence to prove that bias motivated the alleged attack on a Somali Uber driver in Hopkins, Minnesota, despite calls from Muslim and Somali community leaders for a hate crime investigation.
Samit Apurva Patel, 25, has been charged with attempted second-degree murder and first-degree carjacking in connection with the assault on Mohamed Yusuf, who was found severely injured in a ditch.
Yusuf’s family says he remains in a coma. The criminal complaint states that his prognosis is poor.
Attack on Somali Uber driver
Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty said prosecutors could not currently establish beyond reasonable doubt that a specific bias was behind the attack.
“There is insufficient evidence to prove to a jury beyond reasonable doubt that a specific bias was the motivation for Mr. Patel’s actions,” the Hennepin County Attorney’s Office said.
Moriarty said investigators had so far relied largely on an account given by Yusuf’s brother, who was speaking to him by telephone during the incident.
“It’s very difficult to get into somebody’s head and figure out what the motivations are,” she said. “So we don’t have a motive right now.”
Minnesota does not have a separate hate crime statute, but proof that a crime was motivated by bias can be used to increase a sentence. Prosecutors would have to prove both the offence and the alleged bias motivation beyond reasonable doubt.
Muslim leaders called on the FBI to investigate after the attack, amid concerns that Yusuf may have been targeted because of his Somali or Muslim identity.
What the criminal complaint alleges
Police were first called to Patel’s parents’ home shortly after 1am after he returned appearing intoxicated, confused and emotionally distressed, according to the charges.
His parents told officers he had been behaving belligerently and was worried about a “strange vehicle” parked outside their house in the middle of the street.
Investigators later determined that the vehicle was a Toyota RAV4 belonging to Yusuf. The complaint says Patel drove it to a petrol station in Hopkins before passing the scene of the alleged attack and returning home.
Officers described Patel as visibly distressed and difficult to understand. The complaint says he eventually admitted he had “done a lot of f—ed up s—”.
Police allege that Patel first claimed the RAV4 was his before acknowledging that it was not. He reportedly said he had “freaked out at something that’s not there” and added: “I am taking responsibility for it.”
Inside the vehicle, officers found a phone still connected to a call with Yusuf’s brother. The brother told police he heard Yusuf screaming in Somali and saying words including “he kill me” and “I’m dead”.
He also said he heard Yusuf say: “He is choking me with a belt.”
According to the complaint, the passenger initially asked Yusuf his name. When Yusuf replied “Mohamed”, the passenger allegedly said: “F–, I don’t like that name.”
The brother told investigators that the conversation had initially been calm before the passenger demanded that Yusuf turn the vehicle, rather than continue towards his home.
He said the situation escalated shortly afterwards, with Yusuf beginning to scream.
Police used data from Yusuf’s smartwatch to trace the journey to an area near Hopkins Crossroad and Minnetonka Boulevard. A drone detected a heat signature, and officers found Yusuf in a ditch about 15 feet from the road.
The complaint says he suffered broken ribs, a broken leg, spinal injuries, collapsed lungs and extensive internal bleeding, with several organs having to be removed.
Moriarty said prosecutors would review any further evidence relating to the alleged motive as the case progresses.
