Somalia’s constitutional overhaul has plunged the country into a direct confrontation between President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud and the Supreme Court, threatening to deepen a long-running dispute over the balance of power between Mogadishu and the federal states.
The crisis intensified when Mr Mohamud dismissed Chief Justice Bashe Yusuf Ahmed on November 4, a day before the court was due to rule on whether the president could lawfully remain in office for an additional year.
Five judges proceeded with the case after the dismissal and ruled that amendments extending presidential and parliamentary terms from four years to five could not be applied retrospectively to officials already in office. Their mandates, they said, had expired.
The government rejected the judgment and immediately installed a replacement chief justice, setting up a confrontation over both the legality of the constitutional changes and the timing of the next elections.
The dispute is the latest escalation in a two-year struggle over Mr Mohamud’s attempt to complete Somalia’s constitution and introduce direct elections. Reforms intended to strengthen national institutions have instead exposed unresolved tensions over federalism, regional autonomy and control of political power.
Constitutional overhaul tests Somalia’s federal bargain
Somalia has been rebuilding a national government since the collapse of central authority in 1991, when regional administrations formed around clan alliances and developed their own institutions, security forces and sources of revenue.
The provisional constitution adopted in 2012 created a federal system intended to share power between Mogadishu and the regions. But key questions over authority, resources and security were left unsettled, making governance dependent on negotiations between national leaders, regional presidents and clan elders.
Parliament passed the first constitutional amendments in 2024 and approved the remaining changes in March this year, concluding a 14-year review process. The reforms give the federal government greater authority over revenue collection and distribution, elections and the circumstances in which it can intervene in member states.
They also provide for voters to elect members of the federal lower house through a national electoral commission. Parliament, rather than the public, would still elect the president.
Supporters of the changes say the previous system, in which clan elders and delegates selected MPs, deprived successive governments of the legitimacy needed to govern effectively.
Ali Mohamed Omar, Somalia’s state minister for foreign affairs, said retaining parliament’s power to elect the president was a compromise designed to win backing from opposition groups.
Mohamed Ibrahim Moalimuu, a federal lawmaker who supports the overhaul, described the president’s decision to continue with the reforms as “daring”. Successive governments had tried and failed to complete the constitution, he said, while most Somalis still lacked the right to elect their national representatives directly.
“Somalia cannot just remain stuck just because the changes made aren’t considered perfect for everyone,” he said.
Opponents argue that agreements reached without the participation of the federal states cannot be imposed on them. They say the reforms would weaken regional leaders and clan elders, whose influence has been central to the selection of MPs and to negotiations with Mogadishu.
Puntland rejected the first amendments in 2024 and withdrew its co-operation with the federal government. Jubaland followed after a dispute over electoral legislation. Both administrations have their own security forces and revenue sources.
Jethro Norman, a Somalia expert at the Danish Institute for International Studies, said control of ports and trade routes, together with relationships with foreign governments, had allowed some regions to maintain considerable independence from Mogadishu.
He said the proposed changes were intended to give the capital greater legal authority over areas long controlled by the regional administrations, although putting that authority into practice would be another matter.
“What you’re seeing is the federal system crystallising into two camps,” Mr Norman said. “You have Villa Somalia presenting the constitution as completing the state: one person, one vote, multi-party politics, democracy, central federal control over foreign relations and national security, and so on.”
Puntland and Jubaland view the changes as an imposition that undermines the original federal settlement. Their position, Mr Norman said, was that the 2012 constitution represented a bargain between the centre and the regions and could not be rewritten by a parliamentary majority in Mogadishu after the regions had rejected it.
The dispute has also been complicated by regional relationships with the United Arab Emirates. Some federal states retain close commercial and security ties with Abu Dhabi, while Mr Mohamud has accused the UAE of supporting regional leaders in disputes with his government.
In January, the government announced the cancellation of UAE port and security agreements across Somalia. The regional states rejected the decision.
Puntland’s president, Said Abdullahi Deni, has suggested that Somalia may need to reconsider how the country is held together if the constitutional dispute cannot be resolved.
“If a solution is not found for the current debate, Somalis must deliberate and decide on another alternative way to live together,” he said.
Somali academic Afyare Elmi said the government was weakening the fragile consensus behind the 2012 settlement by pursuing changes it could not enforce in states that opposed them.
“This is one of the most dangerous times the Somali political system has faced,” he said. “Somalis are no longer moving in the same direction on the future of the state.”
Dispute spreads beyond parliament
The constitutional argument has increasingly spilled into regional politics and armed confrontation. Puntland and Jubaland have suspended co-operation with Mogadishu, while disputes elsewhere have turned violent.
In June, fighting between government forces and militias protecting a former president and prime minister brought part of the capital to a standstill for two days.
The sharpest dispute has emerged in South West state, where a disagreement over the re-election of President Abdiaziz Hassan Laftagareen in March developed into a struggle for control of the regional capital, Baidoa.
Mogadishu rejected the vote and federal troops removed Mr Laftagareen. Forces loyal to him later seized several strategic towns around Baidoa and clashed with government troops.
South West subsequently held Somalia’s first direct election for a federal state assembly in May. The newly elected lawmakers chose Sheikh Adan Mohamed Nur Madobe, an ally of Mr Mohamud, as regional president the following month.
Mr Laftagareen, now in exile in Nairobi with senior members of his former administration, said he intended to return to Baidoa and remove Mr Madobe’s government. He also said he had repeatedly warned the president against changing the constitution without first securing wider agreement among the political elite.
“Separating powers between the centre and the regional governments saved and kept Somalia together, and making these changes is driving the country apart,” he said.
Mr Mohamud does not face opposition in every federal state. His allies now lead four of Somalia’s six states, where recent elections have also strengthened his Justice and Solidarity Party.
But elections in Hirshabelle have triggered further resistance in the Hiiraan region, where political leaders and elders say longstanding grievances over representation remain unresolved. Armed fighters have occupied parts of the regional administration’s offices in Beledweyne.
Mr Moalimuu acknowledged that recent elections “weren’t totally free and fair”, but said allowing citizens to vote represented an important first step.
Election timetable hangs in the balance
The government has scheduled parliamentary elections for April 15 next year, followed by parliament’s election of the president on May 15. The timetable is based on the new five-year terms, despite the Supreme Court’s ruling that the extension could not apply to officials already serving.
That has left the country facing uncertainty over who has authority to set the electoral timetable and whether the constitutional changes can be implemented while several regional governments oppose them.
Mohamed Mahmoud Dirie, a spokesman for the Somali Future Council, a coalition that includes former presidents and prime ministers, said the group had rejected an invitation to talks in November.
He said the coalition had asked for an international guarantor for any agreement, but that request had been refused, making it difficult to ensure the government would honour its side of a deal.
The political crisis comes as international support for Somalia’s reconstruction is under pressure. The United Nations political mission, which had supported constitutional negotiations, elections and reconciliation efforts, closed in October at the government’s request.
The African Union Support and Stabilization Mission in Somalia, which assists Somali forces fighting al-Shabab, is also facing funding shortages and uncertainty over continued United Nations logistical support.
Uganda has begun withdrawing its bilateral troops and plans to withdraw its contingent from the African Union mission by the end of next year. Humanitarian aid is also declining.
Mahad Wasuge, executive director of the Mogadishu-based Somali Public Agenda think tank, said the country was going through several difficult transitions at once, leaving it increasingly exposed while trust between political elites remained low.
