Cornell University is considering the future of its fraternity and sorority system as a legal challenge threatens to derail the reopened criminal investigation into allegations that a former student was drugged and gang raped on campus.
The case has prompted sweeping restrictions on Greek life, a review led by former US deputy attorney general Sally Yates and a court battle over whether New York Attorney General Letitia James should remain special prosecutor.
Allegations and reopened investigation
The unidentified woman filed a civil lawsuit on 16 September, alleging that she was sexually assaulted at the Chi Phi fraternity house in October 2024.
She claims she was pressured into taking ketamine, smoking marijuana and drinking alcohol, leaving her unable to consent to sex. She reported the incident to Cornell’s campus police, but the Tompkins County District Attorney’s Office initially decided not to prosecute.
The criminal investigation was reopened on 28 September as public anger grew. Student protests and faculty no-confidence efforts followed, prompting New York Governor Kathy Hochul to remove Tompkins County District Attorney Matthew Van Houten from the case.
Ms Hochul appointed Ms James as special prosecutor. Cornell separately announced that Ms Yates would conduct an independent review of the university’s sexual misconduct policies and its handling of the allegations.
Cornell reviews Greek life
Cornell President Michael Kotlikoff suspended parties and other social events at fraternity houses for the remainder of the academic year on 13 October.
He also introduced a “zero tolerance” policy under which any violation would lead to an immediate emergency suspension of the chapter. The university said it would add a case manager to its Office of Civil Rights and allow New York State Police investigators to assist with campus cases.
On 16 November, Cornell announced a wider review of its Greek life system and its links to student housing. Mr Kotlikoff said the process would “consider the future of fraternities and sororities at Cornell”.
The university also plans to extend mandatory in-person consent training to all undergraduates from spring 2027, establish an academic research centre focused on sexual assault prevention and invest in alcohol-free social venues.
Challenge to Letitia James
Five of the seven former fraternity members named in the civil lawsuit have asked a New York court to remove Ms James as special prosecutor. Their lawyers argue that a post she published on social media on 28 September shows she cannot be impartial.
“What this young woman has been forced to endure is horrific and unacceptable,” Ms James wrote. “I’m holding her in my heart and in my prayers. To her, and to all survivors: you’re not alone. We stand with you.”
In response, Ms James appointed Jacqueline Kelly, a former federal civil rights prosecutor and Cornell alumna, as outside counsel to oversee the day-to-day investigation. She has also opposed the petition in court filings.
“Jacqueline Kelly is a seasoned prosecutor who has overseen numerous cases from investigation through trial,” Ms James said. “With her criminal legal expertise, commitment to public service and judicial experience, I am confident that she will lead a fair and comprehensive investigation.”
A judge is now considering whether Ms James can remain in charge of the criminal probe.
Civil case continues
The civil lawsuit names Cornell, Chi Phi, the woman’s former sorority Delta Delta Delta and seven former fraternity members as defendants. The men have denied wrongdoing.
Former Chi Phi chapter president Orazio Petito was later removed from the case with prejudice after the woman’s lawyers concluded that he had been wrongly identified as leading the fraternity when the alleged assault took place.
At least one of the remaining defendants, Diego Sarabia, has asked the court to dismiss the claims against him.
Cornell has said the Chi Phi Xi Chapter remains permanently closed. National Chi Phi interim executive director Trey Robb condemned sexual assault “in the strongest possible terms” and said the fraternity had acted immediately to expel the accused students, while stressing that the national organisation does not have day-to-day control of its chapters.
The court proceedings and Cornell’s broader review of Greek life remain unresolved.
