Pete Hegseth’s impeachment was blocked by the US House of Representatives, but the vote has not cleared the defence secretary of allegations over the Trump administration’s military campaigns, analysts have warned.
Democrats are expected to take control of both chambers of Congress after winning the November 3 midterm elections, raising the prospect of renewed scrutiny of Hegseth once the new majorities are sworn in.
The former Fox News host has faced growing calls to leave office since becoming defence secretary in January 2025. His tenure has included oversight of the war on Iran and deadly boat strikes in the Caribbean Sea and eastern Pacific Ocean, both of which have been accused of breaching international law.
Impeachment motion blocked
Outgoing Republican Congressman Thomas Massie led an attempt to impeach Hegseth less than a week after the midterms. Eight articles filed by Mr Massie accused the defence secretary of dismantling safeguards intended to protect civilians.
Among the allegations was that those changes contributed to the bombing of an elementary school in Minab, Iran, in which at least 120 children were killed. The claims have not been resolved.
The motion was shelved on November 10 when the Republican-controlled House voted 211 to 204 to block it. Eleven Democrats were absent from the vote.
Jasmine El-Gamal, a former Middle East adviser in the Pentagon, said the decision was “not an acquittal nor a vote resolving the allegations” over possible war crimes in Iran and elsewhere. She expects the incoming Congress to continue pursuing the claims.
“Impeachment is just one constitutional accountability mechanism,” Ms El-Gamal said, pointing to congressional investigations and lawmakers’ control over federal spending as other ways to scrutinise Hegseth and President Donald Trump.
Hegseth’s role in the Iran war
Hegseth has rejected calls for his resignation. In a five-minute video released two days after the midterms, he dismissed his critics as “deep-state radicals” engaged in “political theatre”.
“They attack us because we are effective. It’s not going to work. We will not back down,” he said, adding that the military would “stay the course” in the war against Iran.
“We have only just begun to fight,” Hegseth said. “We are more determined than ever, more resolute than ever to finish what we have started.”
Former US diplomat Hala Rharrit said Hegseth and senior Department of Defense officials would have helped prepare the initial list of targets for the first strikes against Iran before advising Mr Trump, who would have given final approval.
“I suspect that Trump would not get into the granularities of which targets to strike on day one,” Ms Rharrit said. “Hegseth and others in DOD had a lot to do with those precise decisions, which also runs through lawyers.”
At least 23 US service members have died and 865 have been wounded in the conflict, according to the material. Iran has retaliated against US and Israeli attacks with strikes across the Middle East.
“Ultimately, they are both responsible, not just for the strikes in Iran, but also for making American service members and diplomats throughout the region sitting ducks,” Ms Rharrit said.
Congress set to challenge Trump
Brian Finucane, a former State Department legal adviser, said Congress had held the power to stop the fighting throughout the conflict. Under the US Constitution, he said, “the overwhelming bulk of war powers belong” to Congress.
He described the midterm result as, in part, a reaction against the Trump administration’s use of executive authority, arguing that Congress had received too little transparency over overseas military operations.
“We’ve seen sort of the apex of presidential unilateralism under Trump,” Mr Finucane said. “I think it has reminded Americans of why the Constitution gives Congress, not one man, the power to take the country to war.”
Democratic Congressman Hakeem Jeffries, who is in line to become the first Black speaker of the House, previously told supporters that Hegseth’s days were numbered. He has since described himself as a “hard yes” on impeachment proceedings against the defence secretary.
Hegseth is not the first Pentagon chief to face pressure after a poor election result. After Republicans lost both chambers of Congress in the 2006 midterms amid anger over the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, President George W Bush announced within a day that defence secretary Donald Rumsfeld would resign.
Vice President JD Vance has also blamed the Iran war for the Republicans’ midterm defeat, writing that “the real reason” was “obvious to almost everyone”. “The reason we lost is the war,” he said.
