A new study published in Psychology of Music finds that listeners rate hooks in unfamiliar pop songs as more attention‑grabbing and memorable after hearing them multiple times, while an auditory verbal distraction makes those hooks feel less catchy. The two laboratory experiments, led by doctoral student Bethany T. Nixon and professor Timothy P. Byron of the University of Wollongong, suggest that catchy pop phrases rely on both how songs are written and how our memory and attention work.
In popular music, a hook is a distinctive melodic, rhythmic, or lyrical phrase that grabs a listener’s attention and sticks in memory, such as the repeating syllables in Kylie Minogue’s “Can’t Get You Out of My Head.” Modern productions layer vocals, drums, bass and harmonies, so the brain cannot process every detail equally and instead filters for standout moments. Researchers say these phrases lodge in verbal working memory—the short‑term mental workspace people use to silently rehearse words and melodies.
Earlier music psychology work began tracing how repetition and attention shape this process, particularly in relation to earworms—the experience of a tune looping in the mind. A 2015 experiment found that playing unfamiliar songs repeatedly increased their likelihood of resurfacing later, while a 2021 pair of experiments indicated that catchy songs occupy verbal working memory in ways that interfere with trying to perform unrelated verbal tasks.
Repetition and distraction shape perceptions of musical hooks
The 2025 study built on these findings by asking listeners to rate short clips from famous pop songs directly. Nixon and Byron recruited undergraduates to judge how much certain phrases stood out and were easily remembered, using an approach that supported self‑report ratings as a direct reflection of thoughts and feelings about the music.
However, testing songs that participants did not know well posed a challenge: could the ratings reflect a song’s design rather than simply prior familiarity? The researchers addressed this by presenting unfamiliar tracks under controlled levels of repetition and distraction to see how each factor altered conscious judgments of hooks.
Experiment 1 involved 66 Australian undergraduates (about 20 years old on average) who listened to two of four unfamiliar songs spanning dance‑pop and hip‑hop‑pop. The tracks—“LA in Two” by ELIO featuring Valley, “KEYS” by Neko Pink, “Hold Your Head” by Ruben Dawnson, and “Tangerine” by grouptherapy featuring Jadagrace and TJOnline—had not featured on the Australian Top 50 and varied in global streaming reach. Each participant heard one song once and the other five times, with the listening occasionally interrupted by an easy sudoku task, then followed by a final undistracted listening and a real‑time rating on a 0‑to‑100 slider while the song played.
When the final undistracted listen was included as a rating pass rather than a true repeat, repetition exerted a clear effect: participants’ hook ratings rose by an average of 6.76 points on the 100‑point scale from the second to the sixth exposure. Chorus sections consistently attracted higher ratings than verses and other sections, and those who enjoyed a song more tended to rate its hooks more highly, with each 1‑point rise in enjoyment linked to about a 2.33‑point jump on the slider.
Surprisingly, solving sudoku while listening did not produce a statistically significant difference in hook ratings, and there was no significant interaction between repetition and distraction. Byron suggested this may reflect how pop songs are often experienced as background music, gradually worming their way into perception even when attention is elsewhere. “We had assumed that the Sudoku task in Experiment 1 would be a good distraction task, but it didn’t seem to distract participants from building up a coherent image of the music in their heads,” he said. “But in retrospect that makes sense – pop songs are often worming their way in while we’re not paying much attention to them.”
To more directly compete with music for verbal and auditory attention, Experiment 2 recruited 98 Australian undergraduates (about 21 on average) and analysed 91 after exclusions for prior familiarity with the songs. The design was revised: no separate undistracted pre‑listening pass, and a 40‑item Goldsmiths Musical Sophistication Index survey was added to gauge whether musical background influenced hook judgments.
In this phase, participants again heard the four tracks, either once or four times, with one condition accompanied by a test of verbal memory—the Rey Auditory Verbal Learning Test—while the music played. In place of sudoku, a researcher read aloud 15‑word lists and asked participants to recall as many words as possible across repeated rounds. After listening, participants heard 20 short clips from each song and rated each clip on a seven‑point scale for how much it stood out and how easily it could be remembered. These clips included both vocal lines and backing instrumental sections, and chorus clips were compared with non‑chorus sections more broadly than in Experiment 1.
Experiment 2 found that repetition and verbal distraction shaped how listeners judged the excerpts. Hearing a song four times instead of once raised excerpt ratings by an average of 0.27 points on the seven‑point scale, while the verbal recall task lowered ratings by about 0.85 points. Across conditions, average ratings were highest after four undistracted listens (4.71) and lowest after a single distracted listen (3.84). As with Experiment 1, chorus clips outperformed non‑chorus clips by around 1.10 points on the seven‑point scale, a medium effect.
Musical background appeared to play only a modest role; after testing subscales of the musical sophistication survey, only self‑reported perceptual abilities and emotional engagement with music remained in the best‑fitting model, together accounting for roughly 10 per cent of the variance in ratings. Participants also tended to rate memorability slightly higher than salience, by about 0.24 of a point, with no strong evidence of interaction across conditions.
Two explanations are offered for the decline in ratings under the verbal recall task during Experiment 2. The authors propose that the test may have competed directly for the same verbal working memory system used to encode music, or that it simply imposed a heavier mental load than the simpler sudoku task. “We suspect that very catchy hooks play some role in earworms – songs getting stuck in your head – so this suggests that one way to avoid earworms is to avoid building up a coherent, clear memory of the song in the first place,” Byron noted.
Despite the distraction, chorus sections maintained their overall advantage. Byron explained: “Our Experiment 2 found that repetition had a small effect on how participants rated excerpts, and that being distracted had a medium effect size. So if a phrase is an effective hook, it will get a fairly high rating from participants even if they heard it once while distracted.” He added: “So chorus excerpts on average got higher ratings than verse excerpts, no matter what condition – people were still rating catchy hooks pretty highly even if they were distracted during the one listen to the song they had. That said, ratings were shown to be significantly affected by distraction and repetition.”
The researchers note that the repetition findings align with earlier behavioral and brain‑imaging work showing that repeated exposure to unfamiliar melodies boosts favorable responses, though the prior work focused on liking and brain reward rather than memorability or salience of specific hooks.
The study’s practical takeaway is candid: avoiding building a memorable, coherent memory of a catchy song could help prevent earworms. “If you want to avoid earworms, avoid building up a coherent, clear memory of the song in the first place,” Byron observed.
Several caveats accompany the findings. Both experiments drew on a young Australian undergraduate cohort, predominantly female, so attention, multitasking and memory patterns may differ in other ages or cultures. The tracks were deliberately obscure to ensure unfamiliarity, which may temper the potency of hooks compared with chart‑topping hits, and self‑reported ratings can blend liking with salience. The authors emphasise that reactions may vary with different backgrounds and that future work should broaden age ranges, cultural contexts and genres beyond pop, as well as explore visual versus verbal distractions and combine self‑report with behavioural or physiological measures.
As Byron reminded readers, hooks can be multi‑faceted within a single track. “Sometimes people think there is just one hook in a song – but more than one phrase in a song can be shown to be salient and memorable,” he said. “It is also important to remember that this study was conducted on a typical Australian undergraduate student population who were likely culturally familiar with the music styles in the songs we chose.”
The researchers, Nixon, Hamden and Byron, conclude that repetitions and distractions shape how people perceive and remember hooks in unfamiliar pop songs, with chorus sections consistently rising to the top of listeners’ attention even under cognitive load. They note the ultimate aim is to understand the role these hooks play in why songs get stuck in people’s heads, a question that will guide future investigations across broader demographics and musical genres.
