A nationwide air travel ground stop that halted flights for five hours has renewed scrutiny of ageing US aviation systems, after government watchdogs warned for years about technical failures, delays and weak oversight.
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said the fault behind Friday’s disruption could be linked to a router that was meant to have been replaced in 2006.
“We’re investigating that right now,” Mr Duffy said. “This goes back decades.”
The Federal Aviation Administration’s telecommunications infrastructure has been operated by L3Harris, and its predecessor Harris Corporation, for around 25 years. The FAA has awarded the company billions of dollars in contracts since 2020.
A 2024 audit found that the agency had extended the original 2002 contract 10 times without proper authorisation. The extensions added 57 months and $1.5 billion in spending, the audit said.
It warned that the FAA “may be repetitively using these noncompetitive extensions for convenience and administrative ease”, creating a risk that it was paying too much while receiving lower-quality results.
Earlier audits had raised similar concerns. A review published four years after the original contract was awarded found that the modernisation programme was behind schedule, while a follow-up report in 2008 identified continuing reliability problems that had disrupted air traffic control operations.
More than 800 flights were delayed after a telecommunications outage in 2009. An investigation concluded that the FAA had not properly overseen Harris Corporation or put sufficient safeguards in place as more services were shifted to private operators.
Despite those concerns, the agency awarded Harris a further $291 million contract in 2012 to update outdated air traffic control voice communications equipment. The project was terminated in 2018 after repeated delays and technical problems, with $160 million spent.
Mr Duffy said after last week’s outage that the government could not immediately replace L3Harris because a new system had yet to be built.
“Many of our contractors, many of our partners, they take our money and they provide really poor service to us,” he said, questioning whether the disruption had been caused by contractor error or faulty equipment.
Eric Soskin, who served as transport inspector general under the Biden administration, said some FAA equipment was so old that a manufacturer of replacement parts had been out of business for more than a decade.
“When you have systems as old as the ones that we have in place now, the knowledge of how those systems work… may even have been lost to retirements or memory,” Mr Soskin said.
He added: “If only we had succeeded in getting a full rollout of next-gen technologies a decade ago, I bet whatever the cause was here wouldn’t have happened.”
Warnings over FAA modernisation
A 2024 Government Accountability Office review found that 51 of the FAA’s 138 air traffic systems were unsustainable because of outdated functionality and missing spare parts. A further 54 systems were considered potentially unsustainable.
The Department of Transportation says $12.5 billion approved for FAA modernisation is being used to replace handwritten processes with electronic systems at 25 control towers, upgrade five facilities that still use floppy disks and modernise 469 tower radios.
However, a September inspector general’s report warned that carrying out upgrades too quickly could itself cause disruption.
Mr Soskin said Friday’s outage demonstrated the need to continue with the upgrades, but added that the FAA and the Department of Transportation needed to supervise projects carefully and ensure systems were reliable and properly procured.
“The transfer needs to be handled carefully,” he said. “It may be that some disruptions like this are unavoidable, in which case FAA and other leaders need to do a good job of explaining to travelers why they happen, and why the end result is worth the trouble.”
L3Harris said it was working closely with the FAA and had completed 70% of the switch from old copper lines to fibre cables. The company said it was supporting the investigation into the November 13 ground stop and took its impact on travellers, airlines and air traffic operations seriously.
The company has also spent millions of dollars lobbying for federal funding to modernise the infrastructure it has operated for more than two decades. Senate records show it paid $23.9 million to lobbyists since 2020, including $2.51 million this year, and pressed Congress on FAA modernisation funding each year.
In testimony this March, Deputy Inspector General Mitch Behm cited a pattern across 50 audits of rising costs and schedule overruns, blaming failures to settle design decisions and the absence of clear plans.