Cricket Australia’s proposed Sandpapergate forum faces a fundamental obstacle before it begins: a lack of trust among those who were involved in the 2018 South Africa tour. David Boon and chief executive Todd Greenberg announced the process in Hobart, only for Usman Khawaja and David Warner to immediately question how independent and transparent it would be.
The forum will not reopen the original investigation or impose further penalties. Its private hearings and the process for deciding which findings are published have nevertheless raised concerns among members of the touring party.
Participation will be voluntary, meaning it may not produce a complete account of events. Khawaja and Warner also questioned the independence of a process in which Cricket Australia’s board could have a role in determining what is released.
The reaction has underlined how little confidence remains around one of the most damaging episodes in Australian cricket. Trust broke down within the team during the 2018 tour, while Cricket Australia responded to fears over its relationship with supporters and commercial partners by imposing severe sanctions on Warner, Steve Smith and Cameron Bancroft.
The governing body also placed numerous staff members under non-disclosure agreements. Cricket Australia has now said those agreements will be waived for participants in the forum, allowing staff who have previously been unable to speak to contribute openly.
Warner said the players had accepted the punishments handed down at the time, and argued that the new process should focus on accountability rather than further sanctions.
“We put our hands up,” Warner said. “We accepted what Cricket Australia handed out to us. It’s not about penalties. It’s just about coming up with transparency and accountability. Todd’s acknowledged on CA’s behalf about the culture at the time with the players and CA. So I respect that.”
Former Australia coach Darren Lehmann backed the proposal, saying it could give players and staff an opportunity to speak about what he described as “a very sad time in Australian cricket”.
“I actually like it, I do,” Lehmann said on ABC Radio. “I think it gives players and staff and everyone involved in a very sad time in Australian cricket as we know – and obviously I was there – it gives you a chance to speak. For me, it’s the light at the end of the tunnel.”
Trust remains central to Cricket Australia’s forum
One possible safeguard would be for a former judge or King’s Counsel overseeing the hearings to decide what is published, while protecting legal rights and individual confidentiality. The terms governing that decision are expected to be crucial to whether the forum can establish credibility.
The original inquiry was conducted quickly, while later reviews of the team’s culture and the players’ experiences left questions unresolved. The penalties also discouraged some players and staff from using Cricket Australia’s integrity hotline, which was seen as carrying the risk of further punishment.
Boon and Greenberg are attempting to move the issue towards closure, after Sandpapergate dominated media appearances involving Khawaja, Warner and other members of the Australian set-up. But the immediate questioning of the forum shows that restoring trust will be as important as uncovering any further detail.
