Taylor Cole and Charles Michael Davis have reunited on screen for Hallmark Channel’s Christmas rom-com Our Holiday Playbook, after a question at last year’s Hallmark Christmas Cruise helped spark the casting idea.
The actors, who previously worked together on The Originals, said Cole’s suggestion during a 2025 panel led to Davis joining the Hallmark project. Hallmark casting director Tatiana Erasme was present at the discussion.
“First, I have to say thank you,” Davis said during a Hallmark Channel press event. “I think you’re the catalyst.”
Cole recalled being asked which actor she would like to bring into the Hallmark world. “I said Charles Michael Davis. The crowd went nuts. I sent him that video and I said, ‘I think you might be getting a call soon.’”
For Davis, the film marked his first Hallmark production. He described it as a story combining “heart and comedy and the family connection”, while also featuring football and baking.
Cole, who has spent the past decade making Hallmark films, said she enjoys explaining the channel’s audience to performers appearing in its films for the first time. She described the fandom as grateful, sweet and deeply connected to the movies.
The new film also reversed the dynamic the pair had shared on The Originals. Davis said Cole had been “a great leader” when she entered his world on that series, while Cole said their existing friendship allowed them to be playful and spontaneous in the Hallmark setting.
“The freedom of knowing each other and knowing what makes each other laugh and being able to be silly and goofy together really helped,” Cole said. “That shorthand was the sweet spot of our relationship.”
Our Holiday Playbook is scheduled to air on Hallmark Channel on Friday November 20 at 8pm ET/PT, with the film available on Hallmark+ the following day.
