Donald Trump’s proposed triumphal arch has been blocked indefinitely after a federal judge in Virginia said she would issue a preliminary injunction halting the project.
District Judge Leonie Brinkema said during a hearing on Friday that she would grant a request from Arlington County’s board, which sued over the proposed structure in October. The ruling prevents construction while the county’s legal challenge proceeds.
The 250ft arch is planned for Memorial Circle, which is in Washington DC but lies on the Virginia side of the Potomac River, close to Arlington National Cemetery and Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport.
Arlington County says the project could increase noise and air pollution, obstruct roads used by emergency services and create public safety risks if the arch also operates as a military complex, as Mr Trump has suggested.
The county has also argued that the structure would damage historic views between Arlington National Cemetery and the National Mall. It says construction could complicate the 24 to 27 funerals held at the cemetery on a typical weekday, while causing wider disruption to road and air traffic.
In court documents, Arlington officials said police, fire and emergency units had responded to about 200 incidents in the area around the circle during the previous 60 days. They warned that visitors drawn by the arch would place further demands on those services.
The county and other critics have accused the Trump administration of moving too quickly through federally required environmental reviews and failing to consider alternative sites. The National Park Service has defended the review process, which was approved earlier this month, and said relocating the arch would undermine its purpose.
Kate Talmor, senior counsel for Democracy Forward, the non-profit representing Arlington County, said: “We are pleased that the court has recognized the irreparable harm that will come to people who live and work in Arlington and stopped the massive vanity project while our case is heard and considered by the court.”
The White House has said the administration will continue to support the project. Spokesperson Davis Ingle said it was “beautiful and fitting” and that the administration was confident it would be “fully vindicated as this litigation proceeds”.
Friday’s decision was the second legal setback for the arch this week. On Wednesday, DC District Judge Tanya Chutkan extended an order preventing the administration from breaking ground until December 3 while she considers a separate challenge.
That case was brought by a group including Vietnam War veterans and was later joined by the governments of Washington DC and Virginia. Nine members of the Kennedy family also sought to intervene last week.
Judge Brinkema indicated that Arlington was likely to succeed in its case, saying in court that she could not see “any way” the government could prevail on the merits.
She also questioned the administration’s argument that the project was authorised by a 1925 law allowing two much shorter columns at the same location, although those columns were never built. Both judges have expressed doubts about that interpretation.
Brinkema described the project as a “rushed job” and criticised the government’s assessment of its environmental and economic effects, particularly the impact of construction cranes, which officials have said would be taller than the arch itself, on the surrounding airspace.
The Federal Aviation Administration has said the arch would not endanger aircraft provided it was lit in a specified way, including by an eternal flame at its summit. Aviation safety experts have nevertheless raised concerns about adding another risk to an already complex airspace, particularly if the structure were to have military capabilities not covered by the FAA’s assessment.
