A new measurement tool designed to gauge prescriptive beliefs about what men and women should do at work and at home has been developed and validated for use on a common scale. The Breadmakers and Breadwinners Prescriptive Gender Role Beliefs Scales allow researchers to assess caregiving and career expectations for each gender separately, with two parallel versions that share identical wording aside from pronouns.”
Prescriptive gender role beliefs describe how people think men and women ought to behave and which duties should fall to each gender in everyday life. In the United States, attitudes to gender still shape how people allocate their time: although 91% of Americans say gender equality is very important, women who work and raise families still spend more time on household chores, while men in heterosexual couples enjoy more leisure time. The gap widens for parents of young children.
Measuring these beliefs has proven tricky. A 1990 handbook catalogued hundreds of measures, but many rely on outdated phrasing or frame questions in ways that distort responses. A 2026 European survey also showed how question framing can skew results: when respondents choose among separate options for equality, traditionalism, and role reversal, many who are traditionalists under standard items actually endorse gender equality.
To address these challenges, Samantha B. Douglas and colleagues at the University of Florida and Wilfrid Laurier University developed the new scales. The project grew from an unexpected pattern in research on unconscious associations with gender and career, as described by the study’s corresponding author, Colin Tucker Smith: “This work was led by Samantha Douglas, who was one of my graduate students at the time.”
Smith explained the genesis further: “At first, we were trying to understand this odd finding from implicit social cognition in which women showed more stereotypic associations on an Implicit Association Test (IAT) between gender and career (vs. family) than did men. Usually we find that men are more likely to show stronger biases in line with the cultural norm, so I was interested in that and Samantha was starting her graduate career and interested in researching gender, so we worked on this puzzle for quite a while.”
He continued: “What Samantha quickly found is that, even though there is a wealth of self-report measures of gender roles, she could not find a single one that did what we needed to do. I don’t want to get too into the weeds, but on an IAT, there are four relationships at play. In this specific case, the effect could be driven by a difference between men and women in the strength of the pairing of 1) women + career, 2) men + family, 3) women + family, or 4) men + career.”
Smith added that existing measures “conflated at least two of these roles,” noting: “In other words, they ask questions like, ‘It’s more reasonable for a woman to stay home and take care of the kids than for a man to do that’ or ‘It is more difficult for a man to choose between his family and his career.’ We really wanted to get at each of these elements separately, so Samantha set about doing that for her master’s work.”
Following seven pilot studies involving 4,693 participants, the researchers refined the instrument to two parallel 12-item scales. One version concerns men and the other women, using identical wording save for pronouns. Each version splits into two six-item subscales: caregiving and homemaking, and career and home maintenance, covering tasks from childcare and cooking to income and home repairs.
Respondents rate how important each duty is to being a man or a woman, using a 1-to-7 scale. The team preregistered recruitment quotas, model-fit indices, and validity thresholds for an online validation that also made the study’s data, analytic code, and materials publicly available on the Open Science Framework.
In total, 375 U.S. adults completed the survey, averaging about 43 years of age, with 51% identifying as women and 47% as men. Six respondents reported other gender identities, 72% identified as White, and the sample was broadly politically moderate to balance liberal and conservative viewpoints. After demographic questions, participants completed both scales in random order alongside established measures of social roles, benevolent and hostile sexism, social dominance orientation, feminist identity, and, for women, willingness to speak up against everyday sexism.
Statistical tests on the 372 participants who answered every item supported the intended two-part structure for both scales across most traditional model-fit indices, though one standard index indicated marginal fit and chi-squared tests suggested poor fit—described by the authors as overly conservative.
The researchers also tested measurement invariance between men and women across three, increasingly strict, levels to ensure the scales were interpreted similarly. Both scales achieved scalar invariance, indicating that observed differences reflect genuine beliefs rather than differences in item interpretation, though some baseline indices hovered near conventional cutoffs and fell just short for the men’s scale.
When assessing convergent and discriminant validity, the four subscales correlated with the Social Roles Questionnaire and the Ambivalent Sexism Inventory as expected, albeit not every individual correlation met the threshold. Analysed together, the scales linked expectations that men focus on careers and women on family with traditional scores on the Social Roles Questionnaire and higher benevolent sexism, which describes protective yet patronising views of women.
Among the women in the sample, the four subscales together predicted both feminist identification and willingness to intervene in everyday sexism—such as speaking up when a waiter hands a bill to a male friend rather than to the participant. Even after accounting for the Social Roles Questionnaire, the new scales continued to predict these outcomes.
Breaking the results down by subscale, the researchers found that for women, the strongest predictor of identifying as a feminist was lower agreement that providing income and safety is an essential part of being a man, alongside stronger support for women’s career roles and men’s family roles. The pattern differed from that observed with the older questionnaire alone, which did not show statistically significant links when the new scales were included.
In relation to willingness to confront everyday sexism, views on career and provider duties for both genders remained linked to speaking up, even alongside the older measure, while beliefs about women’s family roles did not show a unique association with either outcome. The authors suggest that work and financial roles may stand out because people often picture workplaces when considering sexist encounters.
An exploratory, non-preregistered analysis comparing scores by gender, age, and political orientation found no significant gender differences on three of the four subscales among those who identified as men or women; however, men scored modestly higher on caregiving and homemaking expectations. The authors caution that this raises questions about men’s reported beliefs versus behaviour, including whether men overestimate their contribution to housework.
Age showed no clear relationship with the scales, while more politically conservative respondents tended to endorse breadwinner roles for men and caregiving roles for women, though links between political views and nontraditional expectations for men at home or women at work were not statistically significant.
Smith reflected on the finding that men were more likely than women to view family and home care as part of being a man, saying: “I’m not exactly sure what to make of that. In some sense, it makes me hopeful (as a person who thinks caring for one’s family should be an important part of a man’s identity).” He added: “I also wonder if men are being truthful.”
Looking ahead, he emphasised that the scale separates beliefs about work and family from broader gender attitudes, and that the measure could prove useful in everyday settings. “Beyond academic research, the authors propose that the scales could serve as a practical tool for couples and relationship counselors,” noting that surface-level misalignment in childcare, chores, and finances can sap relationship satisfaction. “I don’t think effect sizes are highly relevant here, but I do think the scale has practical significance.”
He also warned of limitations: while the items do not directly embed heterosexual two-parent households, they focus on a middle-class life stage with children and a wage-earning job, omitting other experiences and non-binary identities. “No scale is the ‘one true scale,’” he said, adding that the project “reinforces a gender binary in referring to men and women and not asking questions about other experiences of gender.”
Nevertheless, the authors advocate adapting the scales to explore how prescriptive gender expectations shift across racial, cultural, and other identities, with appropriate validation for any revised version. “I really hope that this measure gets used,” Smith stated, and he envisages further work to demonstrate its usefulness and adaptability to different groups, including specifications such as “a middle-aged man,” “a Black man,” or “a gay man.”
The study, titled Breadmakers and Breadwinners: Measuring Prescriptive Gender Role Beliefs for Men and Women Separately and on a Common Metric, was authored by Samantha B. Douglas, Colin Tucker Smith, and Gregory D. Webster.
