Two nights of mild sleep restriction can subtly blunt how much people enjoy art and perceive its beauty, new experimental research suggests. In a tightly controlled sleep-laboratory study of young adults, participants who slept a couple of hours less than usual reported lower morning alertness and a more muted response to abstract paintings, while judgments about the artist’s race or gender remained unchanged.
Aesthetics, the study notes, concerns how people perceive and respond emotionally to beauty, art and design. Reactions depend on both the visual features of a work and the viewer’s background, mood and personality. The researchers specifically used abstract paintings to capture how viewers interpret form, colour and texture in ways that invite personal meaning.
Health guidelines typically advise adults to aim for at least seven hours of sleep per night, with sleep loss known to impair attention, memory and job satisfaction. Beyond these effects, sleep deprivation alters emotional life in nuanced ways. A 2023 meta‑analysis found that sleep loss broadly drains positive feelings and dampens emotional engagement, though effects on negative emotions vary depending on how sleep is disrupted.
Because positive emotions help attract people to art and creative experiences, the researchers reasoned that shorter sleep could make visual art feel flatter and less rewarding. Previous work directly linking sleep and art appreciation has been limited; for instance, a 2019 study found that when participants slept poorly, empathy influenced judgments of sculpture proportions less than before.
The artwork study was led by Ariadne D. Godinho of Baylor University and Chenlu Gao of Harvard Medical School and Mass General Brigham, with Michelle R. Hebl of Rice University and the project’s senior author Michael K. Scullin, a psychology and neuroscience professor at Baylor who directs the Sleep Neuroscience and Cognition Lab. “Sleep loss is known to cause performance errors and increase disease risk,” Scullin told PsyPost. “Less is known, however, about whether being well-rested benefits ‘the good things’ in life, such as our ability to enjoy artwork and experience beauty.”
The paintings project formed part of a broader, multi-week Baylor initiative examining how restricted sleep affects learning and creativity in college students. The study drew on sleep-monitoring data from the same project and enrolled 75 students in the broader protocol, with 68 healthy young adults completing every phase required for the artwork study. Participants ranged from 18 to 22 years old, with just over half identifying as women and about 56 per cent identifying as non‑White.
Eligible participants were right-handed, native English speakers aged 18 to 29 who normally needed at least seven hours of sleep, had no sleep disorders, and did not have extreme morning or evening chronotypes. Night‑shift workers, frequent nappers and heavy caffeine users were excluded. The team made the data and task materials publicly available online, though the study was not preregistered.
The researchers used a counterbalanced crossover design: each participant completed both a well-rested and a mildly sleep‑restricted phase in a lab, in random order, with each person acting as their own control. After an adaptation night monitored by polysomnography, participants spent about a week at home with sleep logs and wrist actigraphy before returning for the two lab stays.
During the well-rested phase, participants had nine hours in bed each night (10:00 p.m. to 7:00 a.m.); in the sleep‑restricted phase, time in bed was cut to 5.5 hours (1:30 a.m. to 7:00 a.m.). Outside scheduled testing, participants attended classes and performed normal daytime activities, though napping was prohibited and verified with the wrist monitors.
The artwork evaluation occurred after the second night of each lab stay. Upon waking at 7:00 a.m., participants rated their current positive and negative emotions on separate scales and assessed sleepiness before taking a 30‑minute routine to recover from sleep inertia. At 7:30 a.m., they viewed 12 paintings on a computer—drawn from a pool of 24 abstract works split into two counterbalanced sets to avoid repetition. Each image appeared for 15 seconds with a fictitious year and a fictional artist name chosen to imply a White or African American male or female artist.
Participants described what they believed the artist meant to convey and then rated each piece on overall liking, beauty, colourfulness, creativity and artistic skill (on a 1-to-7 scale). They also guessed whether the work came from an amateur or professional venue and estimated how much a curator might pay to acquire it in US dollars.
Brain‑wave data collected in the nights before the art task confirmed the schedules: on the night before the art task, well-rested participants slept on average 8.04 hours, versus 5.19 hours when restricted. Sleep pressure built during restriction, with participants falling asleep faster, spending less time awake during the night and achieving higher sleep efficiency (94.7 per cent of time in bed asleep) compared with 90.4 per cent when well‑rested. Even so, two nights of restriction left participants noticeably sleepier at 7:00 a.m. and lower in positive emotions, while negative emotions did not differ significantly.
The emotional pattern aligns with earlier research on reactions to film clips, which suggested sleepier viewers experience weaker positive feelings, particularly in bittersweet moments, while negative responses remain largely unchanged.
In the main analyses, mild sleep restriction reduced aesthetic appreciation of the abstract paintings. On the 1-to-7 scale, liking fell from 4.53 when well-rested to 4.33 when restricted, and beauty ratings fell from 4.51 to 4.33—a shift of roughly 0.2 points, about 4 per cent.
Not all judgments were affected by sleep loss. Perceived colourfulness, creativity, the skill required to create the work, and the guess that a painting came from an amateur venue showed no statistically significant difference between the well-rested and sleep‑restricted sessions. The order of sleep phases and correlations with time spent in particular sleep stages also did not yield significant effects after removing extreme data points.
Asked what the average person should take from the findings, Scullin said, “When we’re well-rested, we experience more alertness, greater happiness, and apparently, a touch more beauty.”
He described the effect as subtle—a 5 per cent difference in artwork ratings—that most people would likely miss in everyday life, but which could accumulate across thousands of daily interactions with scenery, artwork, architecture, music and people. “A 5 per cent change might accumulate across thousands of everyday interactions with scenery, artwork, architecture, music, people, and other experiences. When ‘5 per cent’ is placed within this larger context, it seems possible that sleep loss could subtly change our quality of life without us ever realising why.”
To understand how sleep loss relates to lower art evaluations, the researchers conducted mediation analyses on 66 participants with complete data, testing morning sleepiness, positive mood and negative mood as mediators for liking. In models for overall liking, both greater alertness when well‑rested and higher positive mood independently linked sleep schedule to painting ratings, and the direct effect of sleep condition on liking disappeared when these mediators were considered—a pattern described as full mediation. Negative mood did not mediate the effect.
For beauty ratings, alertness and sleepiness again formed indirect pathways, with the direct effect of sleep condition no longer significant once sleepiness was included, while positive and negative mood were not statistically significant mediators. Scullin remarked that it was surprising that mood did not mediate the effect on beauty.
The authors note that beauty perception may hinge more on overall brain alertness and sensitivity to subtle visual detail than on specific mood states. They caution that both morning sleepiness and mood were self-reported before the task and may overlap, limiting conclusions about causal pathways.
The study found no evidence that the artist’s identity, signalled only by a fictitious name, biased evaluations, and Bayesian analyses supported the absence of an effect in both well‑rested and sleep‑restricted conditions. The researchers suggest this aligns with prior work indicating mild sleep loss does not reliably trigger overt conscious discrimination, though subtler unconscious associations may appear in other contexts.
Several caveats accompany the findings. The experiment took place in a laboratory with healthy young adults viewing a single art style on a computer screen early in the morning after two nights of mild sleep loss. Results may differ in older populations, in people with longer histories of insufficient sleep, or when engaging with sculptures, music or realistic paintings in real-world settings such as museums. The study also tested multiple rating scales without formal corrections for multiple comparisons, underscoring the need for replication.
Looking ahead, Scullin, who has spoken publicly about sleep health in a TEDx talk, hopes to move beyond laboratory sleep restriction to test how improving rest could bolster everyday well‑being. “We’re interested in how improving sleep quality can help people flourish across all their life domains,” he said. “Experiencing happiness and beauty in life is one sign of flourishing, as is succeeding at work or school and having enriching social relationships.”
The study, Experimental Sleep Restriction Blunts Positive Emotions and Aesthetic Experiences When Viewing Artwork, was authored by Ariadne D. Godinho, Chenlu Gao, Michelle R. Hebl, and Michael K. Scullin.
