Women are retiring with an average superannuation shortfall of $51,000 compared with men, according to an analysis of Australian Taxation Office data by the Super Members Council. The gap has widened to 26 per cent, from 20.5 per cent a decade ago.
The continuing disparity comes as women earn almost 20 per cent less than men over their working lives. The Workplace Gender Equality Agency last week put the gender pay gap at 19.7 per cent.
Lower earnings feed directly into retirement savings, while time away from paid work and reduced hours for caring responsibilities can widen the difference further. Research by Australian Retirement Trust found that nearly one-third of women said caring duties had reduced the hours they could work or the income they could earn, rising to half of partnered women with children.
Only 16 per cent of people surveyed said they felt able to balance immediate financial pressures with longer-term goals. The research also found that 63 per cent of women had checked their super balance in the previous year, but just 17 per cent had reviewed or changed their investment options.
How women can narrow the superannuation gap
One starting point is to examine both the performance of a super fund and the level of risk attached to its investment choices. The ATO’s YourSuper comparison tool, accessed through myGov, allows members to compare their fund with alternatives.
The median Balanced super fund returned 9.4 per cent in the last financial year, according to SuperRatings. However, long-term performance is more important than a single year, with an annual return of 7.7 per cent over 10 years given as the relevant benchmark in the advice.
The choice of investment option can have a substantial effect over time. A MoneySmart calculator comparison showed that a person aged 30 with $50,000 already in super and earning a 6.1 per cent forecast return could accumulate $519,432, compared with $676,941 at a higher rate of return — a difference of $157,509.
The lower figure reflects a Balanced option with up to 70 per cent in growth assets such as shares, while the higher rate is used to illustrate the effect of stronger long-term performance. A more conservative fund, with fewer growth assets, was given a forecast return of 4.9 per cent.
Investment risk needs to be considered alongside age and personal circumstances. In general, younger members have more time to withstand market fluctuations, although the appropriate choice will vary from person to person.
Women on lower incomes may also be eligible for government support. A worker who earns less than $64,293 and makes a $1,000 after-tax contribution to super can receive a government co-contribution of up to $500, provided the other conditions are met.
The maximum payment begins to reduce once income reaches $49,293. The contribution works out at about $19 a week for someone making the full $1,000 payment.
Couples can also consider directing extra savings towards the lower-earning partner’s super account. A higher-earning spouse may be able to contribute up to $3,000 to a partner earning less than $40,000 and receive a tax offset of up to $540.
The spouse contribution option can apply even when the lower earner is not working, making it potentially relevant during unpaid periods spent caring for children. The tax offset begins to reduce once the recipient’s income exceeds $37,000 and disappears at $40,000.
Actuarial firm Rice Warner has also modelled the impact of women typically living about four years longer than men. It concluded that female workers would need to receive 2 per cent more in super contributions to achieve the same level of retirement income across their lives.
The firm took that approach to the Human Rights Commission and was granted permission to pay female employees 2 per cent more on fairness grounds. Workers may also consider whether they can salary-sacrifice an additional 2 per cent into super, although the effect on take-home pay would be lower because the contribution is made before tax.
Any decision about superannuation, investment options or salary sacrifice should take account of individual circumstances and be considered with professional financial advice.
