The Town of Cottesloe is seeking state government funding for a $100,000 study into the feasibility of local government amalgamation, arguing that ratepayers should not have to finance an initiative arising from state policy.
Councillors will consider a motion on November 24 asking the Cook government to meet the full cost of preparing a business case, while expressing a willingness to discuss possible mergers if they could improve services, financial sustainability and community outcomes.
Town officers have recommended that the council support discussions on amalgamation but make clear that an independent assessment must be funded by the state.
They said the six-figure cost would place an “unreasonable financial burden on ratepayers” and argued that preparing a business case was not part of the council’s routine operations.
“A rigorous independent assessment is essential before Council, the community or the state government can reasonably determine whether amalgamation would be in the public interest,” the officers said.
They added that requiring councils to fund such investigations could shift the cost of state-led reform to local ratepayers, regardless of whether a merger proceeded or delivered benefits to the community.
State government says councils must have ‘skin in the game’
A state government spokesperson said local governments had to take responsibility for their future and show leadership when considering structural reform.
“They have a responsibility to determine if they are still fit for purpose, not just for today but in the years and decades ahead,” the spokesperson said.
The spokesperson said ratepayers deserved decisions based on evidence about the potential effect of structural reform on rates, services, assets, staff, representation and the long-term sustainability of their local government.
“An independent business case is not an unnecessary expense, it is a responsible and essential investment in good governance and decision-making,” the spokesperson said.
“The state government should not be expected to fund every preliminary investigation or business case initiated by local governments, they must be prepared to put some skin in the game.”
The question of amalgamation has been raised across Perth’s western suburbs since Claremont mayor Peter Telford wrote to neighbouring councils in October proposing discussions about possible boundary changes and a larger local government.
Mr Telford said the Town of Claremont had authorised talks without endorsing a particular model, with an initial meeting intended to hear the views of other councils and establish what information would be needed.
Several councils have already ruled out pursuing mergers. The City of Nedlands said it would focus on strengthening its financial position over the next year or two before considering amalgamation.
The Town of Cambridge has voted to retain its existing boundaries and not pursue an amalgamation proposal unless it could demonstrate a clear net benefit to the council and its community.
The City of Subiaco has also said it is not considering amalgamation, arguing that collaboration and reform could be achieved through partnerships between councils without changing their boundaries.
