Xabi Alonso’s Chelsea project has produced a mixed early return after 10 Premier League matches, with encouraging attacking signs offset by uncertainty over the team’s shape, midfield balance and defensive consistency.
Chelsea have already suffered four league defeats and are 11 points behind Arsenal, having twice managed consecutive victories. Their 5-1 win over Bournemouth followed disappointing results against Hull and Brentford, while defeats by Tottenham and Sunderland have tempered hopes of a serious challenge at the top.
Injuries have disrupted Alonso’s plans, but the Chelsea manager has also used the opening weeks of his tenure to experiment. The team has begun six matches with a back four and four with a back three, while Alonso has stressed that the shape used during matches matters more than the formation listed before kick-off.
That flexibility has yet to produce a settled identity. Levi Colwill and Wesley Fofana have struggled to convince, but academy graduate Josh Acheampong has emerged as a significant positive in defence.
Goalkeeper and attacking concerns for Chelsea
Goalkeeping remains one of the principal questions. Emiliano Martinez arrived with considerable pedigree but conceded three times on his debut against Brighton and has not always looked assured. His injury has opened the door for Mike Penders, whose response after an unfortunate own goal against Tottenham has given Alonso a decision to consider.
Penders has conceded three goals from chances valued at 4.49 expected goals, while Martinez has let in 11 from shots worth 9.17 expected goals. The figures have strengthened the argument for giving the younger goalkeeper a sustained opportunity.
Chelsea have also endured a spell without a recognised centre-forward. They started without one against Tottenham, Manchester United and Sunderland, with Danny Welbeck used sparingly and Emmanuel Emegha yet to earn Alonso’s trust.
Liam Delap, Nicolas Jackson and Marc Guiu were sold, leaving Chelsea short of an obvious focal point. Morgan Rogers and Pedro Neto have both been used as false nines, although Neto’s deployment in that role has been difficult to justify. Chelsea have scored 19 goals from 15.9 expected goals, but consecutive blanks against Tottenham and Sunderland have raised questions about whether their attacking output can be maintained.
Joao Pedro has provided the clearest solution. He has scored five goals and supplied three assists in six league appearances, and Chelsea’s attack has looked far better connected with him leading the line. The club have scored only twice across the four league matches he has missed, both in the victory over Manchester United.
His form has also helped Cole Palmer, who has started all 10 league games alongside Rogers. Palmer has three goals and three assists and appears close to full fitness, but his influence has been markedly greater when Joao Pedro is ahead of him.
Rogers has also formed a productive partnership with Palmer and has defended his team-mate’s desire to play for England. Palmer’s own international position remains under scrutiny after he withdrew from Thomas Tuchel’s squad with a minor injury in September.
Midfield changes and a lack of control
Alonso has tried six different midfield combinations, with injuries to Moises Caicedo and Reece James contributing to the changes. Romeo Lavia has impressed when fit, while Jordan Henderson appears to have developed a promising relationship with Caicedo.
All three started in the defeat at Sunderland, but the sale of Enzo Fernandez late in the transfer window without an adequate replacement has left Chelsea short of options in the centre. Strengthening that area could therefore become a priority in January.
The uncertainty has been reflected in Chelsea’s possession figures. They have had more of the ball in half of their 10 league matches, but recorded only 26 per cent possession in a 4-3 home victory over Brighton and 31 per cent against Tottenham.
Alonso has acknowledged that his side must improve in possession and use the ball more effectively. The need for greater control was also evident against Manchester United, when a half-time message helped produce an improved performance.
Set pieces have offered both encouragement and concern. Chelsea have scored six goals from dead-ball situations, with only Brighton doing better, in addition to Palmer’s penalty against Manchester United.
However, they have also conceded six set-piece goals, the joint-highest total in the league on the figures available. Austin MacPhee’s arrival from Aston Villa was intended to strengthen that aspect of the team, but Chelsea’s display at Everton was the clearest indication yet that progress is still being made.
Opportunities for Estevao and the next stage
Estevao’s limited involvement is another issue Alonso must manage. The Brazilian teenager has started only one league match, as has fellow 19-year-old Geovany Quenda, while the absence of European football has reduced opportunities for squad rotation.
Estevao made a strong impression when selected against Manchester United and thought he had scored, only for a narrow offside decision to rule out the goal. He returned to the bench for the defeat at Sunderland, despite being regarded as unavailable for sale.
With Joao Pedro established as a key attacking figure and Palmer and Rogers ever-present, Alonso must find a way to involve a player who remains highly valued by Chelsea supporters without disrupting the side’s developing balance.
After 10 matches, Chelsea remain relatively well placed in the race for Champions League qualification, despite their inconsistent results. Alonso has repeatedly said the team will look different in May, but the early evidence suggests there is still considerable work to do before the route from the current side to that intended destination becomes clear.
