The UN secretary-general race is entering its final weeks with no candidate yet able to secure the backing of all five permanent members of the Security Council, raising the prospect of the organisation entering the new year without a confirmed leader.
Antonio Guterres is due to leave office on December 31. Eight candidates are now in contention, but the opaque process of secret polls and private negotiations remains unresolved amid competing interests between the US, Russia, China, Britain and France.
The late entry of Emirati diplomat Lana Nusseibeh and Turkish nominee Feridun Sinirlioglu has further unsettled the contest, which is already being shaped by rival priorities across Latin America, the Middle East and beyond.
Georgina Holmes, a senior lecturer in politics and international studies at the Open University, said the contest represented a “struggle over who will exercise political influence within the UN at a time when multilateralism is under considerable pressure and attack”.
She said the permanent members of the Security Council were “not as politically aligned as they have been in previous eras, arguably even during the Cold War”.
UN secretary-general race remains finely balanced
Costa Rican diplomat Rebeca Grynspan is regarded as the leading contender after a series of informal Security Council straw polls. In the latest poll, held on November 5, she received 12 votes marked “encourage” and three marked “discourage”.
Grynspan, who heads the UN Conference on Trade and Development, has been presented as a continuity candidate. Her supporters argue that she could provide stability, although some question whether she would deliver sufficient reform as the organisation faces political and financial pressure.
Richard Gowan, programme director of global issues and institutions at the International Crisis Group, said Grynspan had “solidified her position as the frontrunner”. However, he said she still appeared to face opposition from the US and Russia, both of which could veto her appointment.
Some of Grynspan’s reports have raised concerns about Israel’s actions in Gaza and the occupied West Bank, positions that conflict with Washington’s strong support for Israel. She has also disagreed with Russian justifications for suspending an agreement allowing grain to be transported through the Black Sea.
Grynspan has met key governments as she seeks support, including Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov in April. Gowan said her team believed Washington and Moscow could still be persuaded to accept her, adding that US officials appeared to be keeping open the possibility of working with her.
Argentina’s Rafael Grossi, head of the International Atomic Energy Agency, finished second in the latest poll, with nine “encourage” votes and four “discourage” votes. His perceived closeness to Washington is expected to count against him with China and Russia, although he has recently used conciliatory language towards both countries.
The other Latin American and Caribbean candidates are Guyanese diplomat Carolyn Rodrigues Birkett, Antigua and Barbuda diplomat Maria Fernanda Espinosa and Ecuadorian diplomat Ivonne A-Baki.
Rodrigues Birkett has faced scrutiny in the US after describing Israel’s actions in Gaza as “genocide”. She received five “discourage” votes in the latest poll, while Espinosa received 10 and A-Baki 14, leaving both of their campaigns looking unlikely to succeed.
Permanent members hold decisive power
Nusseibeh, the UAE’s minister of state, is reported to have support from the US and Russia, while Britain and France have offered little resistance. But she received six “discourage” votes in the latest poll and has faced opposition over allegations that the UAE armed paramilitary forces accused of atrocities in Sudan. The UAE has denied the allegation.
“Nusseibeh’s main challenge is to win over China, which has so far seemed sceptical about her candidacy,” Gowan said. “If she can get Beijing’s support, she could break through.”
Sinirlioglu received eight “discourage” votes and is expected to face opposition from Greece, a member of the Security Council. Ugandan politician Olara Otunnu, the only remaining African candidate, received nine such votes.
Former Hungarian prime minister Viktor Orban, a far-right politician, has also been floated by the US as an alternative choice, although he is not an official candidate.
A successful candidate needs at least nine votes in the 15-member Security Council and must avoid a veto from any of its permanent members: the US, Britain, France, Russia and China. The 193-member General Assembly must then approve the appointment.
Ben Donaldson, an adviser to the 1 for 8 Billion campaign, said a negative vote in a straw poll did not necessarily mean that a permanent member would eventually use its veto.
“It has been used in the past as a basis to extract a concession from a candidate, very often in the form of a backroom deal to get a P5 national appointed to a key role in the future UN boss’s cabinet,” he said.
Concerns over a leadership gap
The prolonged contest comes as the UN faces what analysts describe as near-constant crisis. The organisation has been sidelined in conflicts in Iran and Ukraine, criticised by US President Donald Trump and forced to cut thousands of jobs during a financial crisis.
Ellen Ravndal, an associate professor of political science at the University of Stavanger in Norway, said the drawn-out selection process reflected growing geopolitical tensions and an organisation operating in “near-constant crisis mode”.
Adam Day, head of the Geneva office of the United Nations University Centre for Policy Research, said the contest had lasted longer and been more disputed than the elections of Guterres in 2016 and Ban Ki-moon in 2006, although earlier races had also run into December.
“In the broader scope of secretary-general races, this one is still within the range of what has been normal,” he said. “But the longer it takes, the less time the incoming secretary-general has to prepare a transition.”
The UN Charter does not specify an automatic interim successor if no appointment is made by the end of the year. Any gap would require the Security Council and other UN bodies to agree how the organisation’s leadership and operations should be managed.
Donaldson said there was concern that the US and possibly other influential states were allowing time to run down in order to increase pressure for a less popular candidate, or to leave the UN leaderless and weakened for a period.