A study in Iran has found that two maladaptive personality traits—Antagonism and Disinhibition—are linked to a range of harmful online behaviours on Instagram, including cyberbullying, trolling and catfishing. Led by Mojtaba Elhami Athar of the Darkmind Research Group in Tabriz and published in BMC Psychology, the research examined how extreme patterns of thinking and acting relate to online conduct among university students.
Social media plays a central role in everyday life by enabling communication, relationship maintenance and global community-building. Yet the platforms can also enable harm, with consequences for victims ranging from emotional distress to financial loss.
Building on a body of research that has typically focused on normal personality traits, the authors sought to understand how maladaptive traits—more extreme and potentially dysfunctional patterns—relate to harmful online behaviours. The study looked at a broad set of online activities, from cybercrime and cyberstalking to practices like trolling, catfishing and sadfishing, alongside measures of Instagram use and engagement.
A total of 490 university students in Tabriz took part, recruited online between September 2023 and May 2024 via WhatsApp, Instagram and Telegram. The sample ranged in age from 18 to 46, with an average age of 24, and 76% were women. Participants earned course credit for taking part.
Participants completed an online survey that assessed six maladaptive personality traits—Negative Affectivity, Antagonism, Disinhibition, Detachment, Psychoticism, and Anankastia—using the Personality Inventory for DSM-5 and ICD-11 Brief Form Plus Modified. The survey also measured cyberbullying, Instagram trolling (for example, “I enjoy upsetting people I do not personally know on Instagram”), Instagram catfishing (for example, “I create fake profiles on Instagram”), computer crime, cyberstalking of romantic partners, attitudes toward internet child pornography, sadfishing, Instagram addiction and general Instagram activity. Several measures, including those addressing computer crime, sadfishing and attitudes toward child exploitation, were developed specifically for this study.
In plain terms, the researchers characterised Negative Affectivity as a tendency to experience frequent and intense negative emotions, while Antagonism encompassed manipulation, deceit, hostility, entitlement and low empathy; Disinhibition described acting impulsively without sufficient planning or consideration of consequences, and Detachment signified withdrawal from social relationships. Psychoticism captured unusual perceptions or eccentric beliefs, and Anankastia indicated excessive perfectionism, rigid rule-following, orderliness and control at the expense of flexibility.
The results showed that different forms of harmful online behaviour tended to cluster: those who reported one type were more likely to report others as well. The strongest associations were found among cyberbullying, trolling, catfishing, computer crime and cyberstalking of romantic partners, with sadfishing also showing a positive relationship with these behaviours.
Across the board, Antagonism and Disinhibition emerged as the most consistent predictors of harmful online conduct. Students with higher levels of these traits tended to report more cyberbullying, Instagram trolling, catfishing, computer crime and cyberstalking of romantic partners, as well as more sadfishing. Collectively, these traits explained between 14% and 19% of the differences seen in these harmful behaviours.
By contrast, those higher in Anankastia tended to report fewer instances of cyberbullying, trolling and computer crime, and they were more likely to view internet child pornography as legally and ethically wrong. Antagonism showed the opposite pattern in opinions about child pornography.
Instagram addiction showed the strongest link with Negative Affectivity, alongside Antagonism and Disinhibition. Negative Affectivity was the only trait linked to more frequent daily Instagram use, while Antagonism was the only trait linked to more frequent selfie-sharing. Yet, the traits collectively explained only between 5% and 7% of the differences in everyday Instagram activity.
“Findings highlight differentiated associations between maladaptive personality traits and different forms of online behaviour, emphasising the need for a nuanced understanding of these relationships,” the study authors concluded.
The research contributes to the growing body of knowledge on the psychological underpinnings of harmful online behaviours. It should be noted, however, that the study was conducted among university students, and some of the behaviours studied—particularly computer crime—were relatively uncommon in the sample. The design also does not allow causal inferences, and all data were self-reported. The authors acknowledge that the sample was recruited through convenience sampling, was mostly female, and factors specific to Iran—such as internet restrictions and government surveillance—may have influenced both behaviour and reporting.
The paper, “Maladaptive personality traits and their relations with online behaviour: an instagram-based study,” was authored by Mojtaba Elhami Athar, Joshua D. Miller and Morteza Azizi.
