Kenya’s proposed internet metering law is facing opposition from the communications regulator, telecommunications companies and civil society groups, who warn that mandatory usage tracking could threaten privacy, increase costs and exclude lower-income users.
The Kenya Information and Communications (Amendment) Bill, 2025, sponsored by Aldai MP Marianne Jebet Kitany, would require internet service providers to bill customers according to the amount of data they consume.
Providers would have to give every subscriber a unique meter number, monitor usage, convert the information into readable details and issue consumption-based invoices. They would also be required to submit details of their billing systems, including subscriber meter numbers, to the regulator at least once in every financial year.
The Bill says the changes are intended to prevent unfair billing and ensure consumers pay for the internet they use. But opponents have questioned whether compulsory metering is needed and whether the proposed safeguards would adequately protect personal information.
Privacy concerns over internet usage data
The proposed system does not expressly require providers to record the content of private messages or the websites visited by subscribers. However, civil society organisations have raised questions about the precise usage information that would be collected, and how identifiable records would be stored, accessed and shared.
Demas Kiprono of the International Commission of Jurists Kenya said the regulator already had powers to address billing complaints and protect consumers. The organisation has questioned whether collecting identifiable usage information would be necessary and proportionate to the Bill’s consumer-protection aims.
Critics want Parliament to specify who could access the records, how long they could be retained and the circumstances in which they could be disclosed. They have also called for greater clarity on how the proposed metering system would operate alongside Kenya’s Data Protection Act, 2019.
The debate has been sharpened by separate court proceedings involving university student David Ooga Mokaya. He was arrested in November 2024 over a social media post concerning President William Ruto and later charged with publishing false information.
Mokaya was acquitted on February 19 after Senior Principal Magistrate Caroline Nyaguthii found that the prosecution had not proved its case beyond reasonable doubt. He subsequently petitioned the High Court, alleging that call data records, subscriber details, location data and metadata had been supplied to investigators without his consent.
Those allegations form part of ongoing civil proceedings and are not a final judicial finding. On February 25, Justice Bahati Mwamuye issued interim orders preventing the respondents and interested parties from transferring, sharing or disclosing Mokaya’s personal data without his written consent, a valid court order or an express legal provision permitting disclosure.
The case does not establish that the proposed metering system would be used for surveillance, but it has highlighted the legal questions surrounding the collection and disclosure of telecommunications data.
Regulator warns of affordability risks
The Communications Authority of Kenya has urged MPs not to make consumption-based billing compulsory across the industry. It said the approach could have unintended effects on affordability, digital inclusion and consumer choice, particularly for low-income households, students, small businesses and people in underserved areas.
The regulator noted that background applications, software updates, streaming and cloud services can use data without subscribers closely monitoring their consumption. It has instead proposed alerts when users reach 50, 80 and 100 per cent of their allowance, free real-time usage dashboards and monthly spending limits.
It also recommended independent certification and regular audits of metering systems, clearer itemised bills and stronger procedures for resolving billing disputes. Its position is that consumer protection can be improved through regulation and licensing requirements without imposing one billing model on every provider.
The effect on individual customers would depend on providers’ prices and how much data they use. People with lower consumption could benefit from paying according to usage, while those relying on large or continuous data allowances could face different costs. The Bill does not set the retail prices providers would charge.
Providers warn of higher costs
Telecommunications companies have warned that the proposed changes could increase compliance costs and affect investment in broadband services.
Telkom Kenya chief executive Mugo Kibati told the parliamentary committee on November 10 that mobile internet already accounted for about 96 per cent of data subscriptions and was billed by volume. He said the changes would therefore mainly affect fixed broadband services.
Telkom has called for providers to disclose billing models, charges and fair-use policies before customers subscribe. It also wants users to receive free access to consumption information, itemised bills on request and effective ways to challenge disputed charges.
The company has urged legislators to preserve unlimited and speed-based packages, give providers at least 18 months to comply with any new requirements and require the regulator to receive aggregated rather than individually identifiable subscriber information.
Carole Kairuki, chief executive of the Kenya Private Sector Alliance, said mandatory metering could increase compliance costs and make internet expenses less predictable for businesses, particularly smaller enterprises.
The Bill is now being considered by the National Assembly’s Departmental Committee on Communication, Information and Innovation. Its memorandum says the amendments are designed to protect consumers from exploitation and secure their economic interests under Article 46 of the Constitution.
Parliament must weigh that objective against concerns over privacy, affordability and investment. Telkom chief executive Kibati told the committee: “Sometimes you can go overboard in trying to protect consumers that you actually kill a nascent, growing sector.”
