A new study involving more than 2,600 students at the University of Milan has found that those who devote a larger slice of their waking hours to moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA) report slightly fewer depressive symptoms and somewhat better self-rated health. By contrast, those who spend more time sitting tend to report marginally more depressive symptoms and poorer health. The research appears in Depression and Anxiety.
University students often experience substantial psychological distress. A recent review of Italian studies estimated that 46% of university students show depressive symptoms, 65% experience anxiety, and 85% report significant stress, though figures vary across studies and some data were gathered during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The researchers note that time spent on different activities is interconnected: increasing time for one activity necessarily reduces time for others. For example, adding 15 minutes of exercise means 15 fewer minutes for other activities such as sitting or leisure.
Flavia Pennisi and colleagues explored how the balance of waking time spent in MVPA, light physical activity, and sedentary behaviour relates to depressive symptoms, self-rated health, and eating disorder symptoms. They also used statistical modelling to estimate how shifting time from one behaviour to another would affect these outcomes.
The analysis drew on an anonymous online survey completed by University of Milan students through the university’s official mail system, with a final sample of 2,636 respondents. About 71% were women; 53% were aged 18–23, 32% were 24–29, and the remainder were 30 or older.
Participants reported their physical activity over the previous week using the short form of the International Physical Activity Questionnaire, which records vigorous activity, moderate activity, walking, and time spent sitting. Walking was treated as light physical activity. Depressive symptoms were assessed with the PHQ-9, self-rated health with a single general-health question, and eating disorder symptoms with the SCOFF questionnaire.
On average, students reported 41 minutes per day of MVPA, 58 minutes of walking, and 321 minutes spent sitting. Those with a greater share of time in MVPA tended to report slightly fewer depressive symptoms and slightly better self-rated health, while those who spent more time sitting tended to report slightly more depressive symptoms and worse health. Time spent walking showed no association with depressive symptoms or self-rated health.
The researchers then estimated how reallocating time between activities would relate to the outcomes. Replacing 15 minutes of sitting with MVPA was associated with depressive symptom scores about 0.11 points lower on a 0–27 scale, and with marginally improved self-rated health. A similar pattern emerged when replacing light activity with MVPA, while swapping time between sitting and light activity did not produce meaningful differences.
In contrast, eating disorder symptoms moved in the opposite direction. A greater share of time in MVPA was linked to slightly higher SCOFF scores, while more time spent sitting was linked to slightly lower scores, though these associations were very small.
“These findings suggest that, within the daily movement composition, increasing a greater relative allocation of time to MVPA [moderate-to-vigorous physical activity] at the expense of sedentary time is associated with modestly more favourable mental and perceived health in university students,” the study authors concluded.
However, the researchers caution that the observed associations were very small and detectable largely because the survey included more than 2,600 students. All data were self-reported, which may have introduced recall or reporting biases, and the cross‑sectional design prevents any causal conclusions. The study also did not account for sleep, diet, or socioeconomic status, and the participants came from a single university, which may limit wider generalisability.
The paper, “Physical Activity, Sedentary Behaviour and Mental Health in University Students: A Compositional Isotemporal Substitution Analysis,” was authored by Flavia Pennisi, Antonio Pinto, Marco Colizzi, Carlo Signorelli, Andrea Cozza, Vincenzo Baldo, and Vincenza Gianfredi.
