A new national study in the United States finds that spanking a child at age 35 and hitting a child out of anger by age 40 are connected to largely different personal and household characteristics. Led by Christopher J. Mehus of the University of Minnesota, the research draws on overlapping samples followed over five years and published in the journal Family Process. It suggests that routine spanking and anger-driven hitting may have distinct roots even where milder discipline predicts harsher aggression later on.
The study examined two overlapping samples drawn from the Monitoring the Future Panel Study, which surveys U.S. high school seniors and then follows a random subset into adulthood. The first analysis tracked 18,432 parents from 28 classes at age 35 (with children aged 2 to 12), continuing to age 40. Response rates averaged 89.5 per cent at 35 and 93.0 per cent at 40, with overall retention from 12th grade through age 40 at about 48.4 per cent; statistical weights were used to reflect the original classes despite dropout.
Two survey items measured parental discipline: how often they spanked their children and how often they lost their temper and hit or threw things at them. Responses ranged across seven options from never to every day and were collapsed into “never or almost never” versus more frequent occurrences. Other variables included sex, living with a partner, holding a bachelor’s degree, conservative political views, regular religious service attendance, number of children under 18 at home and year of graduating class. Race or ethnicity, recorded in 12th grade, was used as a rough proxy for cultural experiences and systemic oppression rather than a fixed biological category. A four-item depressive symptoms scale and drinking indicators reflecting criteria for alcohol use disorder were also included.
At age 35, more than half of the sample reported neither behaviour, 34 per cent spanked without hitting in anger, and 9 per cent reported hitting or throwing things in anger, with about two-thirds of those also spanking. The researchers found that spanking and hitting in anger had largely distinct predictors at 35: living with a partner and conservative views predicted higher odds of spanking alone, while a bachelor’s degree was linked to slightly lower odds. For hitting in anger, those three factors did not show statistically significant associations.
Mental health and drinking patterns showed a sharper split: depressive symptoms, disordered drinking, and abstaining from drinking (in contrast to non-disordered drinking) were linked to higher odds of hitting in anger, while these factors did not significantly relate to spanking alone. Fathers were modestly more likely to spank than mothers, but modestly less likely to hit out of anger. Frequent religious attendance and a larger number of children predicted higher odds of both behaviours.
Racial patterns at 35 differed from white parents: Black parents had roughly twice the odds of spanking alone and nearly three times the odds of hitting in anger; Hispanic parents had about two-and-a-half times the odds of hitting in anger, while their odds of spanking alone were not statistically significant. Asian parents showed lower odds of spanking alone and higher odds of hitting in anger, though the small sample size (about 1.7 per cent of respondents) rendered those estimates imprecise.
The second analysis used an overlapping sample of 11,460 parents from 23 classes at age 35 (children aged 2 to 12) and age 40 (children aged 7 to 17) to test whether hitting in anger at 40 could be predicted by prior discipline. Overall, 8.6 per cent reported hitting or throwing things in anger at 40. Narrowing the outcome to escalation from spanking showed that routine spanking at 35 declined by adolescence, yet the key finding remained: those who spanked without hitting in anger at 35 had over twice the odds of hitting or throwing things in anger at 40, compared with those who used neither practice at 35. Those who had already hit in anger at 35 had over eight times the odds of doing so at 40, though the absolute rate at 40 remained relatively small overall.
After controlling for age 40 factors, the analysis found that disordered drinking, depressive symptoms, having more children, and identifying as Black or Hispanic at 40 increased the incremental risk of hitting in anger beyond the 35-year landscape. The estimate for Asian respondents remained imprecise due to small numbers. Other age-40 characteristics, including sex, partner status, education, political views, religious attendance, and abstaining from alcohol, did not reach statistical significance. Class year showed a modest decline in both spanking and hitting in anger across historical cohorts at age 35, but this pattern did not extend significantly to age 40 once age 35 behaviour was accounted for.
The authors offer two possible interpretations of the divergent 35 profiles. Spanking and hitting in anger may have different roots—spanking tied more closely to traditional norms and demographics, while anger-driven hitting may reflect emotional distress—suggesting separate prevention strategies. Alternatively, the differences could stem from how respondents interpreted the terms “spanking” and “hitting” in surveys, regardless of whether the behaviours themselves differed in practice.
The study’s authors caution that, as an observational analysis, it cannot prove causation between spanking at 35 and anger-driven hitting at 40; unmeasured stress or child behaviour could contribute to both. The measures relied on two brief items without a specific timeframe, leaving room for varied interpretation, and the study did not record the exact ages of disciplined children. The sample excluded high school dropouts and men and women who were not part of the original 12th-grade cohort, which may affect generalisability. Attrition over time further complicates the picture, though weighting aimed to mitigate this.
The authors conclude by calling for longer-term studies with more detailed parenting measures to test whether spanking and anger-driven hitting have separate causal pathways and how mental health and substance use shape discipline over time. The research is titled “Exploring Factors Associated With Self-Reported Parental Spanking and Hitting Out of Anger: Cross-Sectional and Longitudinal Analyses Using National Panel Data,” and was authored by Christopher J. Mehus, Ana Mireya Díaz-Howard, Yunqi He, Jaime Ballard, Yvonne Terry-McElrath, Mona Mittal, and Megan E. Patrick.
