A push to elect US presidents by the national popular vote could reach a decisive stage after Democrats secured control of five states that may join the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.
Arizona, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Nevada and Wisconsin could sign the agreement next year, adding 61 electoral votes to the 222 already covered by the compact. The support of at least four of the five states would take it beyond the 270 votes needed for the arrangement to come into effect.
The compact requires participating states to award their presidential electoral votes to the winner of the nationwide popular vote, rather than to the candidate who wins the state. It currently includes 18 Democratic-led states and the District of Columbia.
Democrats will have full control of the five potential new member states next year following this month’s midterm elections. Governors and incoming governors in Pennsylvania and Nevada have said they are open to legislation bringing their states into the agreement, while other governors have not publicly stated their positions.
Supporters believe the development could eventually allow the compact to operate in time for the 2028 presidential election, although significant political, practical and legal obstacles remain.
“I’ve never been more confident that 63% of American voters can get what they want in the 2028 presidential election, which is a national popular vote for president,” said Patrick Rosenstiel, a senior consultant to National Popular Vote, the organisation campaigning for the agreement.
The proposal would require battleground states to surrender the influence they currently hold in presidential contests. Their leaders must also decide whether they want their states to become the decisive additions that move the compact beyond the 270-vote threshold.
Some Democrats have already shown caution. Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs previously supported the measure but has not recently said whether she would back it if the state’s new Democratic majorities sought to join.
Legal and practical obstacles
Critics and some legal scholars argue that the agreement could conflict with the Constitution’s compact clause, which restricts states from entering agreements with one another without Congress’s consent, subject to limited exceptions.
Norman Miller, a constitutional law professor at Willamette University, said the proposal could also create practical difficulties because US presidential elections are administered on a decentralised basis.
States set their own rules on who may vote and how ballots are cast. Mr Miller said requiring electors in one state to follow vote totals from another could generate disputes, particularly without common national rules for voting and counting.
“We would want to have a standardized, uniform set of rules regarding who gets to vote for president, how they vote, how those votes are tabulated, and to have a federal election authority doing that tabulation,” he said.
John Koza, chairman of National Popular Vote, rejected the need for a central bureaucracy, arguing that existing state and federal law already provides for certified vote counts that could simply be added together.
Opponents, including Save Our States, say removing the Electoral College could encourage more regional politics and deepen existing divisions. Mr Miller argued that such a fundamental change should instead be made through a constitutional amendment.
An effort to abolish the Electoral College through an amendment failed in 1969, and Mr Miller acknowledged that securing another amendment would be considerably more difficult than advancing the interstate compact.
Supporters say a national popular vote would force presidential candidates to seek support across the country rather than concentrating on a small number of battleground states. They also argue that it would give voters a greater sense that their ballots mattered.
