Sef Gonzales has failed in his latest attempt to overturn his conviction for murdering his parents and younger sister, but will still be able to challenge the severity of his life sentence before the New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal.
Justice Peter Hamill ruled that the court would consider only the sentence appeal, rejecting Gonzales’ argument that the referral of his case should also allow his conviction to be examined.
A date for the hearing has not yet been set. Unless the appeal succeeds, Gonzales will remain in prison for life without the possibility of parole.
Gonzales was 20 when he killed his 18-year-old sister, Clodine, at the family home in North Ryde, Sydney, on July 10 2001. He strangled, stabbed and beat her before waiting for their parents, Loiva and Teddy, to return home.
He then stabbed them repeatedly and painted an anti-Asian racist message on a wall in an attempt to make the killings appear to have been a hate crime.
Gonzales later called emergency services, claiming he had discovered the bodies. He was found sobbing outside the house and subsequently made a televised appeal for help to identify the killer, offering a $100,000 reward.
He was arrested almost a year after the murders and found guilty by a jury in 2004. His conviction appeal was rejected in November 2007.
Gonzales, who has consistently maintained his innocence, was thought to have been motivated by a desire to claim a $1.5 million inheritance.
Last year, his case was referred back to the Court of Criminal Appeal after he argued that alleged sexual abuse when he was 10 and post-traumatic stress disorder had not been known to the sentencing judge.
In his ruling, Justice Hamill said five judges had considered applications seeking an inquiry into the conviction or a referral of a conviction appeal. “Each was urged to conclude that there is a doubt or question over the applicant’s guilt,” he said.
“All five Judges came to the same conclusion: that the application before them should be refused or dismissed.”
