My Kitchen Rules contestants Harrison and Oliver have rejected claims that they are “secret masterminds” using strategic scoring to advance in the competition, insisting their decisions have been based on the food.
The New South Wales friends made the comments after rising to the top of the leaderboard at the start of the Super Dinner Parties round. Their open and friendly manner has won praise from viewers, but some online speculation has suggested it could be concealing a more calculated approach.
The debate follows a dinner party hosted by Ted and Sheridan, where Simon admitted deliberately giving Zac and Zoe higher scores to keep them in the competition and improve the chances of strong cooks Giancarlo and Tiffany being eliminated.
Harrison said the tactic was questionable but acknowledged that competition could involve difficult decisions.
“It definitely wasn’t the most fair thing to do, but was it a smart thing for Angus and Simon to do as players in this competition? Sure,” he said.
He added that the result had not simply been determined by strategy, arguing that Giancarlo and Tiffany had not cooked the best meal that day.
“It wasn’t really like ‘let the best cook win’ but Tiffany and Giancarlo didn’t cook the best that day anyway,” Harrison said. “I think for us, we were just shocked by how blatant Simon was about it all.”
Oliver said making such an admission ahead of their own Super Dinner Party would have been a risky move. He maintained that the pair had chosen to concentrate on producing the strongest food possible rather than becoming involved in rivalries.
“We approached this competition in our own way and our focus is solely on the food, not anyone else’s personalities, not in any arguments,” he said.
“If he’s going to score like that, we will just make sure that we cook the best we can so that there is no wriggle room for Simon to be strategic.”
Despite their stated focus on cooking, Harrison accepted that the contestants were competing for a $100,000 prize.
“People would do anything to win, you know? So if you’re willing to do anything, that’s the aim of the game,” he said.
Harrison and Oliver deny strategic scoring claims
The pair have also faced suggestions that they could have been quietly using tactics of their own. Harrison dismissed the idea, saying that if their strategy was simply preparing good food, they had performed it successfully.
“If being quietly strategic is cooking good food, then I think we did it quite well because the proof is in the pudding,” he said.
Oliver said the views of the other teams would contradict claims that they were manipulating the competition behind the scenes.
“People who want to, sort of, make any claims that we’re secret masterminds, I think you just need to look at every other team who has spoken to us … and they will tell you it’s not who we are,” he said.
“We wear our hearts on our sleeves. I’ve never been in any situation where I can be anything else but honest, so it’s shocking to hear that’s something that people think.”
The NSW duo also defended the scores they have given throughout My Kitchen Rules, saying their feedback had been consistent and supported by explanations.
“If you look at each time that we score a team, we are pretty consistent,” Harrison said.
Oliver added: “I do feel wholeheartedly that every time we’ve given a score, we’ve backed it up with an explanation of why we gave that score.”
The friends admitted they had felt nervous about being the first team to cook in the Super Dinner Party round, but said they had taken account of criticism from the judges and other contestants.
Harrison said their partnership in the kitchen had helped them cope with the pressure. Oliver described their chemistry as “the secret ingredient to our entire time on the competition”, adding that they could switch between different tasks when needed.
The pair have tipped fellow contestants Mary and Golden, nurses from Victoria, as a team to watch after their Filipino cooking impressed judges, viewers and their fellow competitors.
