Opera Australia has brought Watershed: The Death of Dr Duncan to Melbourne, revisiting the 1972 death of an Adelaide doctor whose drowning helped prompt the decriminalisation of homosexual acts in South Australia.
The production, being staged at the Arts Centre Melbourne’s Playhouse until November 28, follows the death of Dr George Duncan in the River Torrens and the subsequent trial of three police officers. All three were acquitted, and the crime remains unsolved.
First presented at the Adelaide Festival in 2022, Watershed was created by Brisbane composer Joseph Twist, with a libretto by Alana Valentine and Christos Tsiolkas. The production was devised by Neil Armfield.
Its opening image sets the tone: a man hangs above a body of water before descending into it. The staging turns Duncan’s death into a stark physical presence, while the wider story examines the social and legal consequences that followed.
Sebastian Geilings is a striking presence in the production, appearing as the suspended figure and delivering a performance described in the review as deeply affecting. Blake Appelqvist plays the central Lost Boy with sweetness, although the review found his voice lacked resonance.
The chorus emerges as one of the production’s greatest strengths. Twist’s score gives the singers dense layers of harmony and opportunities for individual performers to come forward, creating much of the work’s vocal power.
Twist, whose work also includes music for the children’s television series Bluey, draws on influences including Bach, Stephen Sondheim and Pink Floyd. The result is closer in style to musical theatre than to traditional opera, despite being described in the programme as an oratorio.
The libretto adopts the colloquial language associated with 1970s Adelaide and contains extensive profanity. While the naturalism gives the work a strong sense of place, the review said the combination of blunt language and operatic singing could sometimes tip into caricature and risk trivialising the tragedy at its centre.
Armfield’s direction was praised as powerful and intelligent, although the period-ambiguous costumes were judged less helpful to the storytelling. Despite those reservations, the production places a little-known but consequential Australian story firmly in the spotlight.
Watershed: The Death of Dr Duncan is being performed at the Playhouse, Arts Centre Melbourne, until November 28.
