Two men previously cleared over a fatal road-rage shooting in South Carolina have been charged with murder, while two former Horry County officers face allegations of obstructing justice and misconduct over the investigation.
Weldon Boyd and Kenneth Williams are accused of killing Scott Spivey in September 2023. Former deputy chief Brandon Strickland and former sergeant Damon Vescovi were indicted in connection with the handling of the case.
New charges in South Carolina road-rage shooting
Investigators initially said Boyd and Williams pursued Spivey for several miles after he allegedly pulled a gun during a road-rage incident. Both pickup trucks were said to have reached speeds of more than 100mph.
Spivey eventually pulled on to a side road, got out of his vehicle and told the men to stop following him. Prosecutors allege that the two men then fired through the windscreen of their pickup, striking him in the right side of his back.
In August 2025, South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson declined to prosecute Boyd and Williams, saying the state’s “Stand Your Ground” law applied.
Wilson said the decision had been reviewed by several career prosecutors and was based on eyewitness accounts, toxicology reports, video evidence and forensic analysis.
The law, formally known as the South Carolina Protection of Persons and Property Act, provides protection in certain circumstances where a person reasonably believes they face imminent danger and the use of deadly force is considered lawful.
Evidence emerges during family’s civil case
Spivey’s sister, Jennifer Spivey, later pursued a civil case against Boyd and Williams. Evidence obtained while preparing that case included recordings of phone calls made by Boyd, in which he allegedly discussed the shooting and asked a police officer to intervene.
In another call, Boyd reportedly spoke with Williams about getting teardrop tattoos because they had killed a man. He was also heard saying: “I know it’s (expletive) up to say, but I had a (expletive) blast.”
Body-camera footage allegedly showed another officer writing a note to the men on the day of the shooting which read: “act like victim camera”.
The Horry County Sheriff’s Office dismissed Strickland and Vescovi after the new evidence came to light. The state Attorney General’s Office then reopened its investigation, leading to the latest indictments.
Prosecutors said Boyd made several calls to Strickland from the scene and later, while phone records indicated that the former officer told him he had spoken to investigators and prosecutors about the case.
Defendants deny wrongdoing
Lawyers for all four men have said their clients are innocent. Shaun Kent, who represents Boyd, argued that the charges should be dropped in part because evidence from the civil case had been used to build the criminal prosecution.
Kent also pointed to the earlier decision not to prosecute, saying Spivey had alcohol in his system and had been carrying a firearm during the confrontation.
Strickland’s lawyer told a bond hearing that, although his client’s comments may have been inappropriate, there was no evidence they influenced the investigation.
Vescovi was accused of passing the note about the camera to Boyd and Williams. His lawyer said he had made a poor choice, but believed at the time that the two men were victims of a road-rage incident.
Jennifer Spivey urged the judge to ensure that justice was served, saying: “Scott tried desperately to escape the violence that ultimately took his life.”
Bond was set at $110,000 for Boyd and $100,000 for Williams. Strickland and Vescovi were each granted bond of $10,000.
