Cameron Bancroft’s lengthy statement about Australia’s 2018 ball-tampering scandal has been challenged over its lack of specific evidence against Pat Cummins and the team’s other bowlers.
Bancroft provided detailed accounts of conversations involving Darren Lehmann, David Saker, David Warner, Steve Smith and media manager Kate Hutchison. But when addressing Cummins and the bowlers, his account became less precise, relying on the assertion that “they all knew”.
That distinction is central to the continuing dispute. Knowing that the ball was being worked on is not the same as knowing that sandpaper was being used, and Bancroft himself acknowledged as much in his statement.
“I recognise there is a distinction between knowing a ball is reversing, suspecting it has been altered and knowing specifically that sandpaper has been used,” he said.
However, he did not identify a conversation or particular incident showing that Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood or Nathan Lyon knew sandpaper had been used. All four have issued strident denials, while Cummins denied any involvement when speaking to the media last week.
The missing evidence in the sandpaper scandal
Bancroft’s account included verbatim exchanges about obtaining sandpaper and described Warner as the person who suggested using it. He also portrayed Smith as aware of what was happening but unwilling to engage with it, while recounting his own conversations with Hutchison about the plan.
By contrast, his comments about the bowlers amounted to an assumption that they would have noticed a change in the ball because they handled it frequently. But noticing a difference, and knowing what caused it, are separate matters.
Chadd Sayers also spoke out in defence of Usman Khawaja after taking issue with Cummins’ decision to refer to the state of their friendship. Yet neither Sayers nor Bancroft cited a specific moment in which Cummins or another bowler acknowledged that sandpaper was being used.
The absence of such an example is notable because Bancroft clearly understood the importance of distinguishing between ball maintenance and deliberate use of sandpaper. His statement did not explain how he knew the bowlers belonged in the latter category.
The latest account therefore leaves Warner, Smith and Bancroft as the three players who remain most directly implicated by the known version of events. Warner has accepted that using sandpaper was his idea and said he could not carry it because people were watching him, while Smith has been described as knowing about the plan but not wanting to know more.
The broader issue has never been simply whether the Australian team worked on the ball. That was acknowledged, including by the bowlers. The disputed question is who knew that sandpaper, rather than another form of ball maintenance, was being used.
That is why the claim that “they all knew” carries less weight than a direct conversation or witnessed exchange, particularly when set against the bowlers’ unequivocal denials.
The controversy has also prompted scrutiny of past attempts to alter a ball’s condition. Marcus Trescothick wrote that he carried large quantities of sticky mints in his pockets and used them on the ball to help it swing, raising questions about why he was not challenged by umpires. Former England captains Nasser Hussain and Michael Vaughan have since acted as moral arbiters in the debate.
But the comparison does not remove the distinction at the heart of the Australian scandal. Deliberately changing the ball’s condition was against the rules, while the use of sandpaper represented a more direct and audacious method.
Bancroft may have further stories to tell at a planned closed-door forum. For now, however, his statement has offered detailed allegations about some members of the team but no specific evidence to establish what Cummins and the other bowlers knew.
