Dr Renee Hoenderkamp, a British television presenter who is pregnant at 59, has criticised the backlash against her pregnancy and accused society of applying a double standard to older mothers and fathers.
The GP and co-host of GB News programme The Saturday Five revealed during a live broadcast on November 14 that she was 12 weeks pregnant with her third child.
Hoenderkamp, who already has a 37-year-old son and an eight-year-old daughter, said she had received messages describing the pregnancy as “disgusting”, “revolting” and “selfish”.
Her partner, Colin Natali, will be 66 when the baby is born. The couple’s eight-year-old daughter was born when Natali was 57.
Renee Hoenderkamp challenges criticism of pregnancy at 59
Responding to those who questioned whether it was fair to have a child at her age, Hoenderkamp said older fatherhood was treated differently from later-life motherhood.
“Older fatherhood has long been treated as an eccentricity, sometimes even an achievement,” she wrote. “Yet when a woman chooses to have a baby at 59, the reaction borders on moral outrage.”
She also challenged suggestions that she was having the baby purely for herself, arguing that women in their twenties and thirties were not normally expected to justify their wish to become mothers as an altruistic act.
“Why should that desire suddenly become morally suspect simply because a woman is older?” she said.
Hoenderkamp added: “Society rarely objects when men become fathers at 70 or 80. The double standard is hard to miss.”
IVF pregnancy using frozen eggs
Hoenderkamp conceived through IVF using eggs she had frozen in her thirties. She acknowledged that her age raised questions about whether she would live long enough to see her daughter reach adulthood, but said it was an issue she had considered carefully.
“I cannot promise I will be alive when my daughter turns 30, or even 20. But who can?” she wrote. “Illness and tragedy do not politely wait until someone reaches pensionable age.”
She said the possibility of an earlier bereavement should not automatically outweigh the opportunity for a child to grow up in a loving and secure family.
Hoenderkamp, who became a mother for the first time at 21, said her experience had changed her perspective on parenting.
“At 21, I had youth on my side but far less understanding of what motherhood required of me,” she wrote. “Nearly four decades later, while I have fewer years ahead of me, I also have the wisdom, patience and freedom to make the most of every moment.”
She said the baby would be born into a family where she was wanted and already loved, and argued that her age also brought advantages to motherhood.
