Australian cricket’s ball-tampering dispute has deepened after Pat Cummins rejected Usman Khawaja’s account of the 2018 South Africa tour, while David Warner accused Cricket Australia of maintaining a false version of events.
Cummins used a 68-minute press conference to deny knowing about any plan to tamper with the ball during the tour, including the incident in Cape Town when Cameron Bancroft was caught with sandpaper.
Asked whether he had been aware of any plot to alter the ball, the Test captain answered “no”. His response went beyond denying knowledge of the specific incident and directly challenged Khawaja’s claim in his autobiography that “we all knew”.
Cummins also questioned Khawaja’s conduct as a friend and asked why he had not spoken out at the time if he knew what Bancroft was planning. Although Cummins said he would not pursue legal action after receiving advice that parts of the book could be defamatory, others may yet consider doing so.
Australian cricket remains divided over the 2018 scandal
The dispute has left Australian cricket split between those supporting Khawaja’s version and those backing Cummins and other members of the touring party. Chadd Sayers and Jon Holland, who were reserve players on the tour, have supported Khawaja, as has Warner.
Bancroft said five years ago that the bowlers knew about the ball-tampering plan. When approached by television cameras at an airport this week, he declined to comment “at this time” and smiled knowingly.
Mitchell Starc, Cummins and several coaches involved with the tour have rejected Khawaja’s account. After the press conference, Cummins trained alongside Starc and Josh Hazlewood, with the three appearing to remain united.
Warner has been more outspoken. He accused Cummins of “throwing Khawaja under the bus” and later posted a statement on Instagram questioning whether Cricket Australia had properly investigated the bowlers.
“As far as I am aware, CA [Cricket Australia] did not interview Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc or Nathan Lyon in their 2018 investigation,” Warner wrote. “If that’s correct, then how can CA push the idea that the bowlers didn’t know?”
He added: “It looks like they had decided who they wanted to blame from the very beginning [and] ran a shoddy investigation to serve the purpose and now they want to maintain the false narrative that the bowlers had no idea. That stinks of a cover-up.”
Cricket Australia denied the allegation, saying all players had been given the opportunity to speak during the original investigation and had been able to provide new evidence during the eight years since.
“Subsequently, CA has respected every player and former players’ right to provide their own version of events,” a spokesman said.
Khawaja is due to commentate on Australia’s one-day international against England in Hobart on Wednesday, alongside Warner and Alyssa Healy. He is also expected to appear on podcasts, although at least one interview has been postponed until after the match.
Several other figures connected to the tour have not publicly addressed the latest dispute. Mitchell Marsh avoided a detailed response, while Shaun Marsh, Peter Handscomb and Tim Paine have remained silent. Steve Smith, who was captain during the scandal, has also kept a low profile.
The renewed argument has revived calls for Cricket Australia to publish its original investigation in full or interview those involved again. The report was completed by integrity chief Iain Roy, who left the organisation soon afterwards and has not commented since the controversy returned to public attention.