The US Supreme Court has rejected the Trump administration’s bid to revive cuts to tens of millions of dollars in research grants awarded to the University of California, leaving in place a ruling that the cancellations likely breached the First Amendment.
The justices gave no explanation for their decision, which appeared on a routine orders list. No dissents were recorded.
The case arose after three federal agencies terminated grants to University of California researchers in early 2025, citing executive orders issued by President Donald Trump. Six researchers brought a legal challenge against the cancellations.
The grants had been awarded by the Environmental Protection Agency, the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities. The administration argued that ending the awards was part of an ordinary change in policy and spending priorities under a new government.
In May, a three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit found that the terminations were likely unconstitutional because they were aimed at suppressing viewpoints with which the government disagreed.
The administration subsequently asked the Supreme Court to intervene. Solicitor General D John Sauer argued that “changes in administration invariably bring changes in policy and spending priorities” and that presidents often instruct agencies to review grants that no longer reflect government priorities.
Lawyers for the researchers said the grants had instead been cancelled because of the perceived viewpoints expressed in their work. They alleged that agencies had identified proposals containing what officials considered “dangerous ideas” through keywords in their titles before abruptly ending the funding.
Government agencies said they had used terms linked to diversity, gender and vaccine hesitancy, among others, to assess whether research might conflict with the Trump administration’s policy aims.
Matthew J Tragesser, a Justice Department spokesman, said the administration would continue its legal fight to cancel the grants and defend “the executive branch’s lawful authority to administer federal funding programmes”.
Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of the University of California, Berkeley law school, who represented the researchers, said he was “obviously delighted” by the Supreme Court’s decision. He said it upheld the principle that “the government cannot cut off grants based on the perceived viewpoint of the research”.
Rachel Zaentz, a University of California spokeswoman, said the decision preserved “an important victory for the U.C. researchers whose critical work and federal grants were targeted”. She added that research funding decisions should be based on merit rather than politics.
The 10-campus University of California system has about 560,000 students and employees and receives approximately $17 billion in federal funding each year. It has been a major focus of Mr Trump’s criticism of American universities during his second term.
