The US-Iran frozen conflict is settling into a precarious cycle of limited attacks, economic pressure and maritime disruption, with analysts warning that the arrangement could endure for months while increasing the risk of a return to full-scale war.
The two countries have largely avoided outright confrontation since a June memorandum of understanding collapsed in July. Instead, they have traded intermittent strikes and used sanctions, blockades and pressure on shipping to damage each other’s interests.
Iran says it has recently targeted US military sites in Bahrain and Kuwait, while the United States carried out an air strike on Iran’s Qeshm island on Tuesday. Tehran has also continued attacking ships it says have breached its rules for passing through the Strait of Hormuz.
The US, meanwhile, has maintained economic sanctions and a naval blockade of Iranian ports. The strait, a vital route for global energy supplies, has been blocked or disrupted by both sides.
Iran rejects a ‘neither war nor peace’ stalemate
Washington appears to be favouring economic pressure over renewed military action. President Donald Trump said last week that the war was “effectively over” militarily, while warning that he “would not hesitate” to resume strikes if diplomacy failed.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio said the administration did not need to carry out military strikes if it could achieve the same objective through sanctions and other economic measures.
“The economic pressure on Iran is going to get even worse,” Mr Rubio said.
That approach may be unacceptable in Tehran. Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei has called for an end to the state of “neither war nor peace”, while parliament speaker and senior negotiator Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf said Iran would not remain in such a condition.
“It makes absolutely no difference to us whether the United States wants negotiations or war,” Mr Ghalibaf told parliament on Sunday.
Hamidreza Azizi, a senior Iran analyst at the International Crisis Group, said the two governments faced very different calculations over the cost of continuing the confrontation.
“As economic pressure mounts, Iran may become increasingly willing to take military risks to break the deadlock,” he said.
Oil prices and pressure on Iran
The standoff has already affected energy markets, with disruption around Hormuz contributing to sharp movements in crude prices.
Brent crude reached 117 dollars a barrel in late October, its highest level since April, after trading at about 72 dollars before the war began. It has since fallen to about 92 dollars as vessels continue to pass through the strait despite increased attacks, but remains around 30 per cent above its pre-war level.
Fuel prices in the United States have followed a similar pattern. Average petrol prices stand at 3.80 dollars a gallon, compared with 2.98 dollars before the war, while diesel was just over 5.93 dollars a gallon on November 17, up from 3.72 dollars in February.
Ron Bousso, a columnist who analyses global energy markets, said a prolonged low-level conflict could “put a floor under oil prices” while forcing Gulf exporters to absorb high freight and insurance costs.
He warned that the danger was not only a renewed surge in prices, but a more permanent situation in which shipping remained hazardous, insurance expensive and energy infrastructure vulnerable.
Such conditions would create lasting economic strain for US allies in the Gulf and could make disruption to global energy supplies the “new normal”, he said.
Economic strain raises fears of unrest
Iran faces the heavier economic burden. The United States has continued to sanction Iranian organisations and entities accused of trading with or being connected to Iran, while the naval blockade has made it harder for Tehran to export oil.
Mohammad Farzanegan, professor of Middle East economics at the Center for Near and Middle Eastern Studies, said Iran’s government was prioritising “short-term survival” over sustainable investment as the economy contracted and inflation remained among the highest in the world.
Falling oil revenues were putting pressure on the budget and increasing the need for higher taxes, reduced energy subsidies and difficult economic reforms, he said.
“All these developments have amplified the feeling of deprivation among the population, especially the youth,” Mr Farzanegan added.
Rouzbeh Parsi, an Iran analyst affiliated with Lund University’s Department of History and Human Rights Studies, said the country’s population was suffering the consequences of the economic confrontation.
“While this is not sustainable, long term the question is, if it can hold until Trump leaves office,” he said.
Mr Azizi said Iran’s leadership was concerned that continuing economic pressure could weaken the government and fuel domestic instability while the country was also confronting the US abroad.
Mr Farzanegan warned that another major shock, whether natural or human-made, could trigger a new wave of violent protests. Iran’s ability to preserve the current balance would depend on its capacity to bypass the blockade, find alternative trading partners and address corruption and economic grievances, he said.
Political costs for Washington
The prolonged confrontation also carries risks for the United States. It conflicts with Mr Trump’s campaign pledge to avoid new foreign wars, while a Reuters/Ipsos poll on November 9 found that more than 70 per cent of Americans wanted the conflict to end.
Mr Azizi said Washington had demonstrated overwhelming military superiority but had not compelled Iran to surrender control of the strait or accept US terms.
“The longer this situation continues, the more difficult it becomes to explain what the American strategy is ultimately supposed to achieve,” he said.
Analysts say both governments therefore have reasons to escalate. Iran could decide that a deliberate increase in hostilities was preferable to allowing its economic and strategic position to deteriorate further.
For Mr Trump, the defeat suffered by Republicans in this month’s midterm elections may also alter the political calculations surrounding military action. Mr Parsi said the result had removed what many had viewed as the final restraint against a full-scale war.
He said the president could allow sanctions to take effect, but that the current state of “not-peace” could quickly become a wider conflict if Mr Trump concluded that another attack would end the Islamic republic, or acted out of revenge.
