Benjamin Netanyahu appears to be seeking to exploit divisions within Israel’s opposition alliance as negotiations over the formation of the next government approach a December 6 deadline.
The caretaker prime minister held an unannounced two-and-a-half-hour meeting with former prime minister Naftali Bennett on Wednesday, prompting allegations that he is trying to fracture the bloc assembled to remove him from office.
Netanyahu’s office described the meeting as a security briefing. Opposition figures led by Gadi Eisenkot, however, reportedly viewed it as a serious setback, with one senior member accusing the prime minister of trying to break up the alliance through Bennett.
Bennett is said not to have told Eisenkot about the meeting beforehand. At a subsequent gathering of opposition leaders, he reportedly argued that they should consider forming a unity government with Netanyahu.
Divisions within Israel’s opposition alliance
The meeting has exposed the competing positions within an alliance that spans the political spectrum, from Avigdor Lieberman’s right-wing secularism to the left-wing platform of Democrats leader Yair Golan.
Eisenkot and his electoral partner, Yair Lapid, are regarded as centrist figures. Bennett and Lieberman are on the right, although they differ sharply over religion: Bennett is a religious nationalist, while Lieberman is a staunchly secular politician with strong support among Israel’s Russian-speaking community.
Golan is the most left-wing figure in the group and supports a two-state solution with the Palestinians. He has also condemned settler attacks in the occupied West Bank, accusing the government of encouraging or tolerating them.
All the alliance’s members supported Israel’s military campaign in Gaza, at least in its initial stages, as well as attacks on regional states including Iran and Lebanon. Their differences have been more pronounced over domestic policy and the formation of a governing coalition.
Eisenkot’s bloc won 48 of the Knesset’s 120 seats in the October 27 election, leaving it 13 short of a majority. It must therefore reconcile disagreements among its own members while seeking support from other parties.
Golan has held discussions with parties representing Palestinian citizens of Israel and spoken positively about forming a government with their backing. The proposal has been rejected by other members of the alliance and provoked fierce opposition, including threats of civil war from right-wing protesters.
Lieberman, whose Yisrael Beytenu party has seven seats, has been particularly opposed to relying on Palestinian support. At the same time, his firm opposition to exemptions from military service for ultra-Orthodox Jewish men appears to have softened as the possibility of working with the ultra-Orthodox parties Shas and United Torah Judaism has emerged.
Those parties hold 13 seats between them. Any compromise by Lieberman on conscription could undermine one of his central electoral pledges and expose him to a backlash from supporters.
Previous clashes over Netanyahu and conscription
The alliance’s differences have surfaced repeatedly. In August, Bennett described Eisenkot’s proposal for limited military-service exemptions for ultra-Orthodox men as an “insane mistake”, warning that the ultra-Orthodox politicians Aryeh Deri and Moshe Gafni would “run circles around” him.
Eisenkot responded by accusing Bennett and Lieberman of practising “old politics” and harming the opposition’s electoral prospects by refusing to agree that the alliance’s largest party should lead the next government.
Lieberman also accused Eisenkot of being “Gantz 2.0”, referring to former defence minister Benny Gantz’s decision to join a Netanyahu-led government in 2020 despite campaigning against him. Lieberman claimed Eisenkot was secretly pursuing an agreement with Netanyahu and acting out of personal ambition.
Golan later told Lieberman that if he continued to insist on a government that did not conscript ultra-Orthodox men, he was “welcome to form one with Netanyahu”.
Bennett, who previously served in several Netanyahu governments, broke with him in 2021 when he helped form an alternative administration with Lapid. Their cross-party coalition ended Netanyahu’s 12 consecutive years in office, with Bennett serving as prime minister for the first half of its term.
Despite that break, Bennett continues to share many policy positions with Netanyahu. Lieberman has also previously served as Netanyahu’s foreign and defence minister, while Eisenkot joined Netanyahu’s emergency unity government after the Hamas-led October 7, 2023 attack, serving as a minister without portfolio and a member of the war cabinet.
The opposition alliance has repeatedly pledged not to serve in a Netanyahu-led coalition. But the meeting with Bennett, and the competing demands facing the bloc, have raised fresh questions over whether it can remain united long enough to form a government.