US Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito has warned that proposals to change the court’s composition could permanently damage its independence, as Democrats prepare to take control of Congress in January.
Speaking at a black-tie dinner held in his honour by the American Enterprise Institute, a right-leaning think tank, Justice Alito criticised efforts to influence the judiciary through public pressure and calls for structural reform.
He said opponents of the court’s recent rulings had mounted a campaign involving the intimidation and harassment of justices, or attempts to undermine public confidence in the institution before altering its membership.
“If that campaign succeeds, the Supreme Court as an institution will be fundamentally changed, and perhaps permanently,” Justice Alito told hundreds of guests at the National Building Museum.
He warned that the court could soon face “a structural question of greater magnitude: whether the court will be allowed to continue as an independent tribunal that decides cases based on its understanding of the law, not political pressure.”
Democrats have previously proposed expanding the number of justices, introducing term limits and strengthening ethics rules. The calls have intensified as public approval of the Supreme Court has fallen, with a majority of Americans saying in a September Marquette University Law School survey that the justices were motivated mainly by politics rather than law.
The court’s conservative majority has overturned longstanding precedent in recent years, including by ending race-conscious college admissions policies, removing the nationwide constitutional right to abortion and restricting the authority of federal agencies. Justice Alito wrote the 2022 ruling that overturned Roe v Wade.
Following a decision last term that significantly weakened the Voting Rights Act, members of the Congressional Black Caucus said they would seek term limits for justices. Representative Hakeem Jeffries, the New York Democrat seeking support for his candidacy for House speaker, has also called for lawmakers to “clean up the mess at the Supreme Court”.
Criticism has not been confined to Democrats. President Trump has repeatedly criticised the court, particularly when any of the three justices he nominated has ruled against him.
Justice Alito, who has frequently supported Mr Trump’s policies alongside Justice Clarence Thomas, was the subject of speculation that he might retire after the midterm election. However, he has told people close to him that he does not intend to announce his retirement and plans to remain on the bench at least until the current term ends next summer.
Justice Alito described the judiciary as the weakest of the three branches of government, saying its independence ultimately relied on “the sufferance of the other more powerful branches”.
“What may matter most in the end,” he said, “is popular support for an independent judiciary.”
