New South Wales Premier Chris Minns has deferred new underquoting laws for 12 months, just hours before they were due to take effect, after real estate agents raised concerns about their impact during a sharp property downturn.
The reforms, introduced by the Minns government in June, were intended to give Sydney homebuyers greater transparency and tackle misleading price guides. They included fivefold increases in penalties and a requirement for price guides to appear in all property advertising.
Agents would also have been required to provide a statement of information supporting the estimated selling price and update online advertisements within one business day if the price estimate no longer complied with the law.
The legislation became contentious because of provisions covering the sale price. Agents warned that, in a weakening market, they could breach the rules if they rejected an offer, failed to sell a property and later reduced its advertised price.
The industry raised its concerns with the government on October 22. Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong rejected the argument at the time, saying the reforms would benefit both buyers and agencies.
Mr Minns announced the delay on Monday, saying the issue had been raised by real estate agents in his Kogarah electorate. He said the restrictions could further undermine the industry during the downturn.
Treasurer Daniel Mookhey said the laws had been designed for a market “galloping ahead in price” rather than one in which prices were falling.
However, the decision has prompted questions about why the entire package was postponed rather than only the provision that had caused concern. The premier and Mr Chanthivong did not provide further comment on Tuesday, while Police Minister Yasmin Catley and Attorney General Michael Daley declined to answer questions about the consultation process before the legislation was shelved.
The reforms followed an investigation which found that almost half of all Sydney properties sold at auction achieved prices more than 10 per cent above their advertised guide.
With the laws now delayed, buyers attending auctions across Sydney will continue to face the existing rules, despite having been prepared to expect greater transparency from the start of the week.
