A Tasmanian mother has won a legal battle over the burial of her 19-year-old daughter, after challenging her former fiancé’s right to arrange the funeral.
Elaine Smith was one of three people killed in a two-car crash on the Bass Highway, north of Elizabeth Town, in September. Her mother, Melissa Wells, said two police officers brought her the news at home.
Wells said the loss had left her devastated. “I lost my whole world, she wasn’t just my firstborn she was my person,” she said.
Smith had been with her fiancé for five months, but the couple separated five days before the crash. Despite the split, he accepted the role of senior next of kin from the coroner.
Wells said she raised concerns about the separation, but the coroner still allowed the former fiancé to make arrangements for the funeral. She wanted her daughter to be buried in Kingston, while he planned for the service to take place in Burnie, more than 300 kilometres away.
“I tried to beg not just him, but his mother to be able to put my daughter to rest,” Wells said. “But I pretty much got ignored.”
Legal challenge delayed funeral plans
Wells took the matter to the Tasmanian Supreme Court, arguing that her daughter’s former fiancé did not meet the requirements to be senior next of kin because they had separated shortly before her death.
The legal proceedings put funeral arrangements on hold. The former fiancé was notified about the hearings but failed to appear in court twice and did not answer a call from the court on the day the decision was made.
The court ruled in his absence to quash the coroner’s decision. Court documents noted differences in the way the term “spouse” was defined in Tasmanian legislation.
Wells described the ruling as a “minor relief”, but said the dispute had prolonged her grief and placed a heavy emotional and financial burden on her family.
“Through all the running around (paying for) petrol, from going all the way up to identify her and then having to serve (the ex-partner) the paperwork so he can be a part of the hearings and all the running around in between, I’m not okay in the financial side,” she said.
She said she was worried the costs could affect her family’s Christmas and has launched a GoFundMe appeal to help pay for the funeral and the holiday season.
Wells has urged young Australians to make clear arrangements for who should handle their affairs if they die unexpectedly.
“Please, please tell your loved ones who you want to be able to do this for you, as this may happen to the people you love,” she said.
