Benjamin Netanyahu has been accused of fuelling the threat of political violence in Israel after portraying Arab lawmakers as supporters of terrorism and Jewish politicians willing to work with them as collaborators.
The allegations came after Arab parties made gains in last month’s general election, prompting the Israeli prime minister to attack efforts to form a government that would depend on their support.
Netanyahu said Gadi Eisenkot, whom President Isaac Herzog had tasked with forming a government because he had the backing of a majority of Knesset members, was relying on parties that “agree that the Jewish state must be destroyed”.
He claimed the parties differed only over the type of Palestinian state they wanted to emerge from the ruins of Israel, describing the alternatives as “an Islamic state in the Muslim Brotherhood mould, like Hamas in Gaza, or a nationalist Palestinian state in the Fatah mould”.
The comments have been characterised as depicting Israel’s Arab political representatives as a fifth column, while casting those prepared to work with them as traitors or dangerously naive.
Netanyahu has also been accused of questioning the legitimacy of Arab citizens’ votes after warning during election day of increased Arab turnout. The day after the election, he and his ultra-right-wing allies raised allegations of irregularities in Arab communities in support of claims that the election had been “stolen”.
Warnings over echoes of Rabin assassination
The latest confrontation has revived scrutiny of Netanyahu’s role in the atmosphere surrounding the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin in 1995.
Rabin became a target for Israel’s religious-messianic right after signing the Oslo Accords in pursuit of a peaceful resolution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Several rabbis issued a ruling known as din rodef, or “the law of the pursuer”, accusing him of giving parts of the Land of Israel to non-Jews.
Yigal Amir, who assassinated Rabin, cited the ruling as a justification for the killing. Netanyahu was then leader of the opposition and chairman of the Likud party.
He did not condemn all of the campaign against Rabin and attended a protest in Jerusalem at which the prime minister was depicted wearing a Nazi uniform. Rabin’s widow, Leah, later said Netanyahu was present and did not stop the display.
Netanyahu never apologised or expressed regret over the episode. Several months after Rabin’s assassination, he was elected prime minister.
The current accusations come as Netanyahu faces what has been described as a powerful incentive to remain in office, including concern that leaving government could threaten his efforts to prevent his corruption trial from reaching its conclusion.
He previously offered Mansour Abbas and his Ra’am party the chance to join his own government when it served his political interests. His critics say he is now condemning his rivals for considering the same arrangement.
Netanyahu has also been criticised for legitimising Israel’s messianic far right and bringing its representatives into government. He appointed Itamar Ben-Gvir, who had been convicted of incitement to racism and supporting a terrorist organisation, as national security minister.
Ben-Gvir previously attracted attention after taking the emblem from Rabin’s car and declaring on television: “We got to his car, and we’ll get to him too.”
The warning from Netanyahu’s critics is that the intensity of the present rhetoric could encourage an extremist to attack an Arab or Jewish politician seeking to co-operate with Arab representatives. They also fear it could provoke attacks on Arab citizens, wider communal violence or even civil war.
Israel is therefore facing a renewed risk of political violence, with Netanyahu accused of bearing substantial responsibility for the conditions that have brought the country to the brink.