A 69-year-old woman who described herself as a “Galactic Emissary” has lost her appeal against the cancellation of her firearm licence in Western Australia, after a tribunal ruled she was not a fit and proper person to possess a gun.
May-Ring Chen challenged the decision by the WA Commissioner of Police at the State Administrative Tribunal in May. The ruling was handed down this week.
Her licence was cancelled after police raided her home during an operation targeting firearm owners who had expressed views associated with sovereign citizen ideologies.
The tribunal heard that Chen had sent affidavits to the state’s Governor and Police Commissioner under the name “Yuna”, which she said was her “soul name”. The documents described her purpose as being a Galactic Emissary and stated that she lived on the planet known as Earth.
They included assertions such as “truth is sovereign” and “the malicious designs of men must be thwarted”, as well as the phrase “he who leaves the battlefield first loses”.
Chen repeatedly denied that the documents existed after they were shown to the tribunal. She argued that she had rescinded them and therefore could not comment on their contents.
The tribunal rejected that argument, saying it was unaware of any rule giving her the right to “rescind” a document containing relevant and probative evidence.
The State Solicitor’s Office argued that Chen had meant the contents when she wrote the affidavits. Its lawyer, Nick John, said she was entitled to her beliefs but described them as dangerous.
Chen denied being a sovereign citizen. Her evidence said she was an honest person who rejected violence, upheld natural law, common law and God’s law, and had no criminal or traffic history.
But the tribunal upheld the police commissioner’s decision, finding that Chen had sent pseudo-law manifestos to government officials on at least three occasions.
“These documents make it clear that the applicant does not consider herself bound by laws passed by the parliament and perceives some pseudo-legal effect in proactively announcing as such,” the judgment said.
It added that although Chen had not engaged in violent conduct, she held ideas “which are capable of leading to violence”.
The case followed Operation Ascendant, in which WA police carried out 70 searches across Perth suburbs and regional towns. Officers seized 135 firearms, cancelled or suspended 44 firearm licences and inspected 26 firearm storage units.
Several people affected by the operation have since taken their cases to the State Administrative Tribunal or the WA Supreme Court.