Mental health professionals who took part in a structured session of rapid, continuous breathing reported psychedelic-like shifts in consciousness and rated the technique’s clinical potential well above its risks, according to an exploratory study published in npj Mental Health Research. Clinicians saw promise for conditions such as depression and anxiety, but urged caution for severe psychiatric disorders, emphasising that firsthand enthusiasm does not prove medical efficacy.
High ventilation breathwork refers to practices that involve prolonged, deliberate hyperventilation, typically performed for 30 minutes to several hours while lying down in a group setting with trained facilitators and emotionally evocative music. Unlike slow-paced breathing exercises aimed at simple relaxation, sustained fast and deep breathing lowers carbon dioxide levels in the blood and shifts blood acidity, triggering physical sensations such as tingling or muscle tightness alongside changes in brain blood flow and nervous system activity.
Scientific interest in these breathing practices has grown alongside psychedelic-assisted therapy, as substances like LSD and psilocybin can evoke intense shifts in perception and emotion but face strict legal regulations, high costs, and medical safety constraints. In a 2023 review, researchers outlined how rapid breathing modulates brain chemistry and bodily awareness, proposing that it could eventually serve as a non-drug tool in psychiatric care.
Building on that idea, a 2025 study led by Martha Nari Havenith, who is also a co-author of the new paper, found that drops in exhaled carbon dioxide during circular breathing were linked to the onset of psychedelic-like altered states of consciousness, and deeper altered states predicted later gains in well-being and lower depressive symptoms.
Research on classic psychedelic substances has also investigated why individuals respond so differently to altered states. For example, a 2021 systematic review of 14 studies found that people higher in personality traits like openness and acceptance were more likely to have positive, mystical-type experiences, whereas those who felt apprehensive or scored lower in openness were more likely to experience acute distress.
To test how practicing clinicians evaluate rapid breathwork after experiencing it themselves, and whether similar psychological factors shape their clinical judgments, Ulrike Lueken of Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin and the German Center for Mental Health led an exploratory study asking therapists to complete a standardized breathwork workshop and assess its potential uses and risks.
The researchers used a single-group before-and-after design without randomization or a separate control group. They recruited psychiatrists and psychological psychotherapists in Berlin who were either licensed or in advanced postgraduate training and already treating adult patients, excluding clinicians who worked solely with children and adolescents. Volunteers underwent two rounds of screening to exclude anyone with respiratory, cardiovascular, or neurological conditions, pregnancy, regular use of psychoactive or heart medications, or a history of fainting, panic disorder, recent panic attacks, bipolar disorder, psychosis, or adverse reactions to prior breathwork.
Between November 2024 and January 2025, 54 professionals attended six workshops, and 48 completed the assessments included in the final analysis. Participants had an average age of 38, three-quarters were female, and about 60 percent were fully licensed therapists. Roughly two-thirds trained in cognitive behavioral therapy, with smaller numbers specializing in psychodynamic or systemic therapy, and only four participants held medical degrees. Just over half had never tried breathwork before, while roughly 42 percent had prior experience.
The workshop itself was designed in consultation with Havenith, who is an experienced breathwork facilitator and was involved in conceptualising and conducting the new study as well as leading the 2025 breathwork study it builds upon. Two days before attending, participants watched a standardized informational video and joined an online preparatory meeting with the facilitators and fellow attendees. The four-hour workshops took place on Friday or Saturday afternoons in an adapted Berlin martial arts studio arranged with warm indirect lighting, covered mirrors, and eyeshades, with up to 15 participants supported by four experienced facilitators.
Each workshop began with an introduction, a mindfulness exercise, a sharing circle, and explicit consent choices specifying whether facilitators could offer physical touch. Participants then completed a 50-minute breathing session accompanied by curated music, consisting of roughly 30 minutes of continuous, deep mouth inhales connected to relaxed exhales without pauses followed by 20 minutes of relaxed breathing. An online group integration meeting was held the following morning.
Before the workshop, participants reported their clinical background, prior breathwork experience, and Big Five personality traits in an online survey. In the days afterward, they rated physical and cognitive side effects, overall pleasantness and unpleasantness on a 100-point scale, and the intensity of altered states of consciousness, including feelings of bliss, unity, and spiritual insight. They also completed a questionnaire on emotional breakthrough, which measures whether someone confronted and worked through difficult emotions they usually push aside, alongside 100-point ratings of the technique’s therapeutic potential and risks, written reflections, and judgments about which psychiatric conditions seemed promising or unsuitable.
Physical sensations were more pronounced than cognitive ones, with muscle cramps, changes in body temperature, and feelings of tension or restlessness rated highest, while milder cognitive effects included brief disorientation or a reduced sense of reality. Even with these physical symptoms, participants rated the workshop as much more pleasant than unpleasant, with an average pleasantness score of about 61 out of 100 compared with roughly 24 for unpleasantness. On measures of altered consciousness, the highest ratings appeared for blissful states, feelings of unity, and spiritual experiences, while anxiety and impaired cognitive control stayed low. Emotional breakthroughs fell near the middle of the scale, averaging about 52 out of 100.
The researchers also plotted these altered-state scores alongside published data from separate studies on LSD, psilocybin, and ayahuasca to provide descriptive context. Because those figures came from independent studies, the team did not perform a formal statistical comparison across datasets. Visually, breathwork produced feelings of unity and bliss within a range similar to moderate doses of those psychedelic drugs, though visual imagery was weaker. The authors suggest that because the effects of rapid breathing can be adjusted or stopped simply by returning to a normal breathing pace, the method could help familiarize patients with altered states before considering drug-based psychedelic therapy.
Overall, the clinicians rated the therapeutic potential of high ventilation breathwork well above its anticipated risks, averaging 68 out of 100 for potential compared with 28 for risks. In exploratory statistical models accounting for age, gender, and personality traits, clinicians who were older, scored higher in openness to experience, or experienced stronger emotional breakthroughs during the session rated the practice’s therapeutic potential higher. Other personality traits showed no statistically reliable link to perceived potential, and the overall model predicting perceived risks fell just short of statistical significance.
When asked which clinical populations might benefit, participants pointed primarily to internalising disorders, which centre on inward emotional distress rather than outward behavioural problems such as aggression or impulsivity, giving the highest ratings to social anxiety disorder, depression, somatic symptom disorder, and generalized anxiety disorder. By contrast, they identified schizophrenia and psychosis, dissociative disorders, bipolar disorder, and autism spectrum disorder as unsuitable. They were also more hesitant about post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and panic disorder than other anxiety conditions.
As the authors note, rapid hyperventilation can trigger dissociation, a core feature of PTSD, and closely mimics the physical symptoms of a panic attack. At the same time, deliberately provoking those bodily sensations, a technique known as interoceptive exposure, is an established first-line treatment for panic disorder, leaving breathwork’s role in these conditions unresolved.
In open-ended written responses, about two-thirds of the clinicians highlighted intense emotional processing as a potential benefit, alongside expanded perspective and bodily awareness. On the risk side, more than six in ten warned of psychological destabilization or worsening symptoms, while others cited blurred therapist-patient boundaries, heightened suggestibility, dissociation, and inadequate aftercare.
“The main takeaway is that mental health professionals, after personally experiencing high ventilation breathwork, perceived its clinical potential as outweighing its risks. However, this tells us about therapist expectations and subjective experiences, not about clinical efficacy. A similar design with reiki or another alternative therapy might well yield comparable results,” Jussi Jylkkä, a senior researcher with Transform AI at the University of Turku in Finland who holds PhDs in psychology and philosophy and was not involved in the study, told PsyPost.
The clinicians’ subjective accounts align with an earlier brain-imaging study of experienced breathwork practitioners, which similarly found that rapid breathing safely induced feelings of bliss and unity linked to reduced blood flow in a brain region involved in bodily awareness and heightened nervous system arousal, though that research focused on physiology in seasoned practitioners rather than clinical evaluations from therapists. The connection between emotional breakthroughs and positive therapeutic expectations also echoes an earlier survey of people with past psilocybin experience, which found that stronger emotional breakthroughs predicted greater expectations of antidepressant benefits, though that study examined past drug users’ views on psilocybin rather than mental health professionals assessing breathwork.
When considering how the new study fits alongside research testing whether breathwork actually reduces symptoms, Jylkkä pointed to several recent studies, including a randomized placebo-controlled trial of brief high ventilation breathwork. “Regarding experimental evidence, there is an observational study from the Maastricht group (Uthaug, Mason, Kuypers, Ramaekers and colleagues, 2022) on Holotropic Breathwork showing modest improvements in well-being, and a waitlist-controlled trial on conscious connected breathing for anxiety (Blake, 2026) that showed surprisingly large effects — though without an active placebo control, expectancy effects cannot be ruled out.”
“Fincham et al. (2024) conducted a placebo-controlled RCT on brief HVB with retention and found effects on mood and well-being. So there is emerging experimental work with promising results, but the evidence base remains thin,” he said.
Holotropic Breathwork and conscious connected breathing are two structured forms of prolonged, continuous rapid breathing. The randomized controlled trial Jylkkä cited tested brief high ventilation breathwork paired with breath-holding phases against a masked comparison breathing routine in healthy adults.
In clinical research, a waitlist-controlled trial compares participants receiving an intervention against people waiting to receive it later. An active placebo control, by contrast, uses a believable comparison exercise to help separate a technique’s physical effects from expectancy effects, which are improvements driven by believing a treatment will help.
There are a few caveats to keep in mind regarding the new study. Because there was no control group, the design cannot isolate the effects of rapid breathing from the wider workshop setting, including the evocative music, group sharing, supportive facilitators, and preparation. In addition, the sample consisted of self-selected clinicians in urban Berlin, many participants were not new to breathwork, and past psychedelic drug use was not recorded, which may have leaned the group toward more optimistic evaluations.
Although about 85 percent of the clinicians had direct experience treating depression, none reported clinical experience with dissociative disorders, and only a small fraction had worked with bipolar disorder, autism spectrum disorder, or schizophrenia, meaning most were making recommendations about patient groups they had not personally treated. The exploratory analyses linking openness, age, and emotional breakthroughs to perceived potential also relied on a small sample of 48 participants and surveys completed days after the workshop, so those patterns require replication in larger, independent groups.
“The main risk for a general reader is confusing perceived therapeutic potential with demonstrated efficacy. The study shows that therapists found the experience promising — it does not show that breathwork works as a treatment,” Jylkkä said.
The study authors note that controlled clinical trials with actual patient populations and longer follow-up periods are needed to test whether high ventilation breathwork reduces mental health symptoms and to monitor any lingering positive or negative aftereffects. They add that any future therapeutic use would depend on thorough medical and psychiatric screening, explicit consent procedures covering physical touch and heightened suggestibility, and structured psychological follow-up care.
The study, “High ventilation breathwork as a non-pharmacological model for inducing psychedelic-like states: expert evaluations of therapeutic potential and risk,” was authored by Ulrike Lueken, Isabel Dziobek, Martha Nari Havenith, Marie Schild, and Laura Stefanie Daedelow.
