Nick Carter has criticised Melissa Schuman’s request to keep the transcript of her deposition sealed in their ongoing court battle, accusing the singer of trying to conceal evidence that he says undermines her sexual assault allegations.
In court filings, Carter challenged Schuman’s application relating to her April 2026 deposition, in which his lawyers questioned her about claims against him.
The Backstreet Boys star described the request as the “total embodiment of hypocrisy and regret”. He alleged that Schuman had chosen to publicly campaign against him rather than bringing her case anonymously.
Carter also claimed that, before the lawsuit was filed, Schuman had attempted to interfere with his business arrangements and repeated what he says were false allegations in a documentary and television interviews.
He argued that the deposition transcript should not be protected from public scrutiny, claiming it would show that Schuman’s allegations were a “clear fabrication”.
“Out of one side of her mouth, [Melissa] publicly defames and vilifies [Nick] with horrendous lies and, out of the other side, asks this court to shield her ongoing fraud and perjury from being exposed,” he said in the filing.
Schuman sued Carter over an alleged assault at his Los Angeles apartment in 2003. Carter has firmly denied the allegations.
He further claims that Schuman conspired with another woman, Shannon Ruth, who has also accused him of sexual assault, in an attempt to pressure him through false allegations.
The legal cases remain ongoing.
