Benjamin Ayres’ surprise cameo in Hallmark Channel’s Our Holiday Playbook came about after he accidentally wandered on to the wrong film set, according to co-star Taylor Cole.
Ayres appears as a referee during the family football competition in the film’s final scenes. Cole said the pair’s previous work together helped turn the unexpected encounter into an impromptu appearance.
The actors previously starred together in the 2022 film Long Lost Christmas and have also taken part in several Hallmark Christmas Cruises.
How Benjamin Ayres’ surprise cameo happened
Cole said Ayres was filming another movie across the street when he spotted the catering area for Our Holiday Playbook and walked over. A production assistant recognised him from Hope Valley: 1874, where she had also worked.
“He was shooting a movie across the street and he saw our crafty and went straight to crafty,” Cole said. “The PA on our movie recognised him because she was the PA on Hope Valley: 1874. And so she was like, ‘What are you doing?’ And he was like, ‘I’m shooting the movie. Where’s my trailer.’”
Ayres had confused the two productions, Cole explained, and then knocked on her door. “He got the sets confused and so he knocked on my door and I said, ‘What are you doing here?! You’ve gotta make a cameo. We gotta make this happen,’” she said.
Cole’s co-star Charles Michael Davis joked that the incident sounded like the storyline for another Hallmark film. “This sounds like the plot of the next Hallmark [movie]. Wanders onto the wrong set and…” he said.
The story at the centre of Our Holiday Playbook
The film follows Lexi Bell, played by Cole, as she returns home for Christmas and joins forces with former football star Eddie, played by Davis, to help her family break its losing streak in the annual Bell Bowl.
In return for helping him win a bake-off, Eddie agrees to pose as Lexi’s boyfriend and join her team. As their families’ Christmas traditions bring them closer, the pretend relationship begins to develop into something genuine.
Cole and Davis’ characters end the film together. Asked whether the pair would still be competing a year later, Cole said they had realised they were taking part for their family because “it brings joy to their family”.
Davis added: “I think they’ll keep doing it. I think the pressure and meaning behind it will change. Fun and family.” Cole agreed, saying: “That’s exactly what it is.”
