DNA from a severed head found in a rubbish bag has led to the arrest of a California woman and her mother over the death of a 73-year-old man who had never been reported missing.
Mary Fitzmaurice, 45, has been charged with murder, while her 75-year-old mother, Georgia “Gwinn” Fitzmaurice, faces an accessory charge, according to the Placer County Sheriff’s Office.
The victim was identified as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr after investigators used genetic genealogy to trace possible distant relatives. His remains had initially proved too badly decomposed to identify.
DNA helped identify California cold-case victim
A dog walker found a rubbish bag containing a human head on 28 September 2022 in the Todd Valley area of Foresthill, about 55 miles north-east of Sacramento. The discovery was made while the Mosquito wildfire was burning nearby.
Following an autopsy, forensic experts developed a preliminary profile of the victim’s age and race and produced an artist’s impression. Investigators compared it with missing-persons cases but found no match.
The victim’s DNA was also entered into the CODIS database, without producing an identification. In January 2024, detectives sent the sample for genetic genealogy testing, which generated possible links to distant relatives.
Deputies and FBI agents then traced the man’s family and established that he had been living in Citrus Heights with his wife, Georgia Fitzmaurice, and their adult daughter, Mary.
Sheriff Wayne Woo said investigators believed Mary Fitzmaurice was responsible for her father’s death and that the women had “conspired to dispose of his remains”.
Authorities also allege that the pair continued receiving his Social Security benefits and California public pension while maintaining the impression among relatives and friends that he was still alive.
Some of his estranged relatives were reportedly told that he was “being a recluse” and would disappear for days before returning home for a few days at a time, Mr Woo said.
Investigators have not released a possible motive. The rest of Paul Fitzmaurice’s remains have not been found, and a search of the family home uncovered no further remains, Mr Woo said.
