A new study analysing early school-age children found that those who regularly practised a musical instrument tended to score higher on a range of cognitive tests and on measures of academic achievement, compared with peers without musical training. Brain scans suggested a potential difference in a right-hemisphere white matter pathway linking auditory and motor regions, though this finding was not statistically robust after adjustments for multiple comparisons. The study appeared in Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience.
Scientists note that childhood is a crucial period for brain development, during which environmental experiences can shape neural structure and function. The research adds to a body of work suggesting that extracurricular activities, such as learning to play an instrument, may contribute to cognitive growth during this stage.
Previous work has shown musical training can sharpen music-specific abilities like rhythm and pitch, but several studies have also reported benefits extending to non-musical skills, including executive functioning, reading comprehension and language. Some of these improvements have been accompanied by changes in brain activity and connectivity.
Central to the study was the arcuate fasciculus, a bundle of nerve fibres that connects regions involved in language, auditory processing and related functions. While previous research has linked its structure to language learning and musical ability, the exact relationship between musical training and brain development in children remains unclear.
Lead author Kelsie L. Lopez of Northeastern University, with colleagues, sought to examine whether musical training is associated with higher cognitive scores and with microstructural properties of the arcuate fasciculus. The team analysed data from the FITKids2 study, a randomised controlled trial of a physical activity programme for 7- to 9-year-olds in East Central Illinois. Importantly, they used data collected before any physical activity programme began, and there was no music intervention involved.
The researchers hypothesised that instrument-playing children would perform better on cognitive and academic measures and that their white matter would differ in the arcuate fasciculus.
Musical training status was based on caregiver reports, with children classified as musically trained if they played an instrument and practised for more than 30 minutes per week. Of 175 children with complete data, 38 were musically trained and 137 were not. About 58 per cent of each group were girls, and piano was the instrument most commonly played (29 youths), followed by string instruments (violin, viola or cello) and plucked strings (guitar or ukulele).
Participants undertook a battery of cognitive assessments, including the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery, Third Edition, which measures general intelligence and other cognitive abilities, and the Operation Span task for working memory. They also completed the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement, Second Edition, covering mathematics, reading, spelling, writing and listening comprehension. Of the 175 children, 96 had usable brain imaging data.
To address the imbalance in group sizes, the researchers matched musically trained children with untrained peers of similar age, sex and socioeconomic status. Cognition and achievement were compared in two matched groups of 38, while brain-imaging analyses used two matched groups of 25.
Results showed that musically trained children outperformed their peers on several cognitive measures, including general intelligence, brief intellectual ability, reasoning, spatial relations, verbal comprehension, visual-auditory learning and working memory. They did not differ on some measures of cognitive efficiency and planning. Musically trained children also scored higher on composite measures of academic achievement—reading, mathematics and written language—and on most individual subtests.
In brain imaging, researchers identified a possible difference in the right arcuate fasciculus, along the tract linking the precentral gyrus (a motor region) and the posterior superior temporal gyrus (an auditory region). Children with musical training showed a higher mode of anisotropy in this pathway, suggesting fibres tending to run in a single direction. However, this difference did not remain statistically significant after correcting for multiple comparisons, and no differences emerged in the left hemisphere or on other measures of white matter structure.
“When comparing children who regularly practice an instrument to children without musical training, children with musical training outperformed children without musical training on assessments of cognition and academic achievement and demonstrated higher mode in the right PCG-STGp tract within the arcuate fasciculus [the pathway connecting the precentral gyrus and posterior superior temporal gyrus]. Taken together, results of the present study provide evidence for the value of playing an instrument in the childhood window of rapid cognitive and neural development,” the authors stated.
Researchers caution that the study cannot establish causality. They note that children who play instruments may also benefit from broader family enrichment and greater involvement in extracurricular activities, which could contribute to higher scores.
Limitations include reliance on caregiver reports for musical training and the lack of data on practice intensity or proficiency. The matching process excluded many non-musically trained children from analyses, and the brain-imaging component involved a relatively small sample scanned at a relatively low resolution.
The paper, “Musical training is associated with cognitive outcomes and white matter microstructure in middle childhood,” is authored by Kelsie L. Lopez, Yaen Chen, Roger Burtonpatel, Lauren Raine, Arthur F. Kramer, Charles H. Hillman and Psyche Loui.
