Dwain Hall has been sentenced to life in prison for the first-degree murder and kidnapping of Sonia Exelby, after a Florida jury heard how he exploited her severe mental health problems and lured her to the US with the promise of a violent death.
Hall, 54, had spent two years grooming Ms Exelby on a fetish website, where he used the name AlphaSadist. Prosecutors said he preyed on her depression, bipolar disorder and longstanding belief that she did not deserve to live.
The 32-year-old musician travelled from her home in Portsmouth to Florida in October last year after agreeing to pay Hall about £3,000 to stab her. Her body was found a week later in a shallow grave beside a highway, after she had been stabbed four times.
Hall pleaded not guilty, but jurors found him guilty after deliberating for one hour and 20 minutes. The verdict brought an end to a four-day trial attended by Ms Exelby’s sisters, Gemma Isaj and Sara Exelby, and her brothers Luke and Barry Wilton.
The evidence heard by the Florida jury
The court was shown notes Ms Exelby wrote during her flight to the US, revealing her fear and uncertainty about what she was doing.
“I’m screaming like I’m in a saw trap,” she wrote. “I want to beg for help so badly, but there’s such a wall it will never happen.”
In a message sent to a friend the following day, while she was being held inside a rented cabin in Reddick, Ms Exelby said she was locked inside and was too frightened to take Hall’s gun and shoot him.
“I’m so scared I’m so broken and in so much pain all I can do is lay here and doing what [he] wants makes him respect me enough not to do the things I really hate,” she wrote.
The prosecution presented more than 90 pieces of evidence and called 30 witnesses, including Ms Exelby’s sisters. Much of the material was considered too disturbing to report.
Hall was arrested after charging £900 to Ms Exelby’s debit card for his roadside repair business. Police also found her DNA on a customised knife.
After almost five hours of questioning, Hall admitted responsibility for her death but denied murder and kidnapping. His lawyer, Junior Barrett, did not call a witness and argued that Ms Exelby had been capable of carrying out everyday tasks and organising her trip to Florida.
Dr Jason Demery, a clinical neuropsychologist, told the court that Ms Exelby was “conflicted and ambivalent” and frightened about whether she would go through with the plan.
“Ms Exelby was a highly vulnerable, mentally ill female,” he said. “Her mental illness is quite clear, based on the correspondence I read – that would be clear to almost anyone.”
Sonia Exelby’s history of mental illness
Ms Exelby had been placed in foster care as a child after her father’s drug abuse and her mother’s mental health problems. Her family said the trauma contributed to bulimia, anorexia, self-harm and a need for intensive therapy and medication.
She had twice attempted to take her own life between the ages of 24 and 26. Her sisters told the court that she had warned them in November 2023 about sadistic men contacting her online.
Sara Exelby said the family had contacted police over threats being made against her sister.
“It was absolutely terrifying to think she was in such a vulnerable state that there were these awful people out there taking advantage of her – it was petrifying,” she said.
Gemma Isaj told the court that her sister had visited suicide forums seeking support, but had encountered people preying on her and others she had met online.
Ms Exelby had been a classically trained musician who played guitar, piano and flute. She studied music at South Downs College in Waterlooville, performed at open-mic nights and sang in a choir.
Her family said she was also passionate about video games and animals. Sara described her as “such a beautiful soul” and said they had not believed anyone could harm her.
In court, Hall sat several rows in front of the family and did not look at them during the proceedings. Prosecutors described him as a predator who was sexually aroused by the rape and torture of women.
The family is now seeking to establish an organisation aimed at protecting people with mental health problems from exploitation.
